Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackEnglish/status/972737346398498816
edited the title to include the sentence itself
Source Link
herisson
  • 84.5k
  • 9
  • 216
  • 368

Why does "We went swimming later in the following phrase sound old fashioned?afternoon, Jack and I."

"We went swimming later inWhy does the afternoon, Jack and I."following phrase sound old fashioned?

We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I.

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it'sits basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack"Jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase., right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma? Am I crazy in thinking that the above format sounds more formal than: Jack "Jack and I went swimming later in the afternoon.afternoon"?

I'm adding some more information that has come up through the conversation below:

I pulled the line from a Young Adultyoung adult book written in 1942. I'm studying the text and trying to identify elements that make it 'feel old.' One of these elements is a general presentation of phrases in a more formal way (as compared to other modern YA publications.)

Why does the following phrase sound old fashioned?

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it's basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase. right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma? Am I crazy in thinking that the above format sounds more formal than: Jack and I went swimming later in the afternoon.

I'm adding some more information that has come up through the conversation below:

I pulled the line from a Young Adult book written in 1942. I'm studying the text and trying to identify elements that make it 'feel old.' One of these elements is a general presentation of phrases in a more formal way (as compared to other modern YA publications.)

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

Why does the following phrase sound old fashioned?

We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I.

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into its basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "Jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase, right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma? Am I crazy in thinking that the above format sounds more formal than "Jack and I went swimming later in the afternoon"?

I'm adding some more information that has come up through the conversation below:

I pulled the line from a young adult book written in 1942. I'm studying the text and trying to identify elements that make it 'feel old.' One of these elements is a general presentation of phrases in a more formal way (as compared to other modern YA publications.)

added 354 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
CanDMan
  • 59
  • 1
  • 3

Why does the following phrase sound old fashioned?

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it's basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase. right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma? Am I crazy in thinking that the above format sounds more formal than: Jack and I went swimming later in the afternoon.

I'm adding some more information that has come up through the conversation below:

I pulled the line from a Young Adult book written in 1942. I'm studying the text and trying to identify elements that make it 'feel old.' One of these elements is a general presentation of phrases in a more formal way (as compared to other modern YA publications.)

Why does the following phrase sound old?

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it's basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase. right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma?

Why does the following phrase sound old fashioned?

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it's basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase. right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma? Am I crazy in thinking that the above format sounds more formal than: Jack and I went swimming later in the afternoon.

I'm adding some more information that has come up through the conversation below:

I pulled the line from a Young Adult book written in 1942. I'm studying the text and trying to identify elements that make it 'feel old.' One of these elements is a general presentation of phrases in a more formal way (as compared to other modern YA publications.)

Source Link
CanDMan
  • 59
  • 1
  • 3

Why does the following phrase sound old?

"We went swimming later in the afternoon, Jack and I."

I am trying to describe what is happening here by breaking the sentence down into it's basic components, but I am having difficulty doing this. The "jack and I" part is the Noun Phrase. right? Is there a certain language formality to placing this at the end of the sentence behind the comma?