Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackEnglish/status/1595477292351791105
antemigratory copyedit to improve clarity and formatting
Source Link
tchrist
  • 137.3k
  • 49
  • 376
  • 609

Is the usage of "that"‘that’ in this clause correct“I miss the day that I was trouble-free” ok, or must it use ‘when’?

I miss the days that I was trouble-free. In this sentence:

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if "that" isthat were replaced by "whenwhen," but can "that"would that also be correct here?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of clauses that denote the time of occurrences, one in which no "that" or "when" is needed (the day she left), and the other type in which "when" is necessary (the days when I had to walk home alone after school).:

  1. one type in which neither that nor when is needed
    (e.g., the day she left), and
  2. the other type in which when is necessary
    (e.g., the days when I had to walk home alone after school).

I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas whereas in the second type, the action usually spans a period of time.

I'mI’m confused and didn'tdidn’t find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

Is the usage of "that" in this clause correct?

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if "that" is replaced by "when," but can "that" also be correct?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of clauses that denote the time of occurrences, one in which no "that" or "when" is needed (the day she left), and the other type in which "when" is necessary (the days when I had to walk home alone after school). I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas in the second the action usually spans a period of time.

I'm confused and didn't find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

Is the usage of ‘that’ in “I miss the day that I was trouble-free” ok, or must it use ‘when’?

In this sentence:

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if that were replaced by when, but would that also be correct here?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of clauses that denote the time of occurrences:

  1. one type in which neither that nor when is needed
    (e.g., the day she left), and
  2. the other type in which when is necessary
    (e.g., the days when I had to walk home alone after school).

I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas in the second type, the action usually spans a period of time.

I’m confused and didn’t find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

edited title
Link
1 Tom
  • 33
  • 4

Is the useageusage of "that" in this clause correct?

added 15 characters in body
Source Link
1 Tom
  • 33
  • 4

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if "that" is replaced by "when," but can "that" also be correct?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of adverbial clauses ofthat denote the time of occurrences, one in which no "that" or "when" is needed (the day she left), and the other type in which "when" is necessary (the days when I had to walk home alone after school). I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas in the second the action usually spans a period of time.

I'm confused and didn't find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if "that" is replaced by "when," but can "that" also be correct?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of adverbial clauses of time, one in which no "that" or "when" is needed (the day she left), and the other type in which "when" is necessary (the days when I had to walk home alone after school). I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas in the second the action usually spans a period of time.

I'm confused and didn't find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

I miss the days that I was trouble-free.

I know it would be correct if "that" is replaced by "when," but can "that" also be correct?

Also, I have this faint feeling that there are two types of clauses that denote the time of occurrences, one in which no "that" or "when" is needed (the day she left), and the other type in which "when" is necessary (the days when I had to walk home alone after school). I think in the first type, the action described is often transient, whereas in the second the action usually spans a period of time.

I'm confused and didn't find the answer after several searches.

Any help would be appreciated.

added 103 characters in body
Source Link
1 Tom
  • 33
  • 4
Loading
Source Link
1 Tom
  • 33
  • 4
Loading