17

When people talking about their gender pronouns, why do people use all 3 components?

For example, I identify myself as a male, so I understand the use of "HE", but why people use "HE/HIM/HIS"? Is it possible to have your gender pronoun as "HE/HER/THEM"?

(FYI, I'm not a native English speaker but fluent)

5
  • 11
    For potential answerers, all the current answers talk about the reason for specifying any kind of gender pronoun at all, but that' snot what the OP is asking for. They are asking about why the three one for nominative, one for accusative, and one for possessive.
    – Mitch
    Commented Feb 2, 2020 at 16:17
  • 2
    There are not "three forms" to a personal pronoun; there are five. For example: I, me, my, mine, myself or they, them, their, theirs, themself.
    – tchrist
    Commented Feb 3, 2020 at 4:16
  • 1
    Reading the answers below, I've decided to buzz in for deviation from the English language as we know it.
    – Steve
    Commented Apr 14, 2021 at 6:42
  • @Mitch - is the second one accusative or dative? (Serious question: I wanted to know what the three cases/declinations/whatever were for "identity pronouns" and it is surprisingly hard (for me) to query the interwebs for this - so I came here and found this question with your comment. IMO only your comment is truly the answer. But this page here uses "dative" for what seems to be the second (middle) one - where you said accusative.)
    – davidbak
    Commented Aug 23, 2022 at 23:03
  • @davidbak The second is called 'accusative'. The answer at that link is not how people usually say it (linguists, English teachers). 'Dative' is just not used to describe English. For direct and indirect object, for personal pronouns, the forms me, him, her, us, them are called accusative. By the way, my comment contains no answer at all, just suggests that answers should address the 'why three parts?' rather than 'why at all?'.
    – Mitch
    Commented Aug 24, 2022 at 0:01

6 Answers 6

17

People who have gender identities that conform to their biological sex (oft referred to as "cisgendered") can show solidarity with the trans community by offering our own pronouns whenever appropriate, thereby helping to normalize the practice. If all trans people used "he," "she," or "they," simply giving a nomative pronoun would allow the listener to extrapolate all other pronouns. However, some trans people prefer to use Neopronouns, which don't always declinate in a intuitive way, such as e/em/es or thon/thon/thons. Neopronoun users give their nomative, accusitive and predicative possessive pronouns out of necessity, so those of us using standard pronouns follow suit.

1
  • 3
    Verbs conjugate; pronouns decline. And this is an excellent point.
    – Aaron K
    Commented Feb 2, 2020 at 12:52
5

There are now a number of additional pronouns, mostly used by people who identify as non-binary (neither 100% male, nor 100% female, or a third gender). Most people are not familiar with them, so don't know how to use them when only one is presented. If one pronoun is "xe" or "chis", what are the others? Can you work out the rules without being told?

The generally accepted pronouns are not regular, in fact they're highly irregular so they have to be memorised. Most people have not had enough exposure to these additional pronouns to have memorised them and be familiar with them.

This is why two, three, or even the full set of five pronouns will be mentioned.

1
  • 1
    +1. Of course, that assumes your audience knows that there are five forms, and how to use them.
    – GEdgar
    Commented Feb 2, 2020 at 19:09
3

Not all people want others to use the standard pronouns, whether masculine feminine or plural. Other possible pronouns exist such as ze, hir, zirs etc. Many people are unfamiliar with the usage of those and what the object and possessive forms are, so it makes sense to specify all of the ones you want to be called by in each circumstance.

3

The three pronoun format (e.g., "he/him/his") is an obvious and hard-to-misunderstand way of communicating a person's personal gender pronouns. It is just convention, and even then, the two pronoun format (e.g., "he/him", dropping the possessive) is even more popular now. Just "he" wouldn't be very obvious, and could even be mistaken for "she" when spoken. And, as an aside, I've never seen more than 3 forms of the same pronoun listed either, since that would just increase the amount of words used without making the message any more clear.

The reason personal gender pronouns are even stated at all is primarily fueled by the LGBTQ community, which has many members who are gender nonconforming and whose pronouns cannot be (easily) guessed. However, stating pronouns also benefits people outside the LGBTQ community, such as anyone with a gender-neutral name or appearance.

According to an NPR interview (no relation to me):

Why are pronouns typically given in the format "she/her" or "they/them" rather than just "she" or "they"?

The different iterations reflect that pronouns change based on how they're used in a sentence. And the "he/him" format is actually shorter than the previously common "he/him/his" format.

"People used to say all three and then it got down to two," Heng-Lehtinen [deputy executive director of the National Center for Transgender Equality] laughs. He says staff at his organization was recently wondering if the custom will eventually shorten to just one pronoun. "There's no real rule about it. It's absolutely just been habit," he says.

But he notes a benefit of using he/him and she/her: He and she rhyme. "If somebody just says he or she, I could very easily mishear that and then still get it wrong."

The interview also explains what it means when there are two different pronouns listed, like "she/they": it's used to indicate the person wants to be referred to with either/both pronoun sets. (In the case of "she/they", that's "she/her" and "they/them".) While "he/her/them" (mixing cases of pronouns) would not be used, some people do go by the pronouns "he/she/they", like one person in the article How To Affirm the People in Your Life Who Use Multiple Sets of Pronouns. Another rare occurrence is people who go by "any pronouns", which is similar to "he/she/they" but technically includes neopronouns.

See also my answer to Is it correct to say your pronouns are "she/they" or should it be "she/them"?.

2
  • 1
    'The previously common' three-item format was made necessary by the fact that some of the neopronouns are such that those who were unfamiliar with them could not be sure what their accusative (object) and possessive forms are, if they were not all stated explicitly. It was then used even for the traditional pronouns, were it was not strictly needed, so that the format would be the same for all pronouns. The choice between the three-item and two-item formats is thus not entirely arbitrary, as the quoted interview seems to suggest.
    – jsw29
    Commented Aug 28 at 16:01
  • @jsw29 Neopronouns are a factor I considered, but I couldn't find any evidence to back it up. Why not state the full five forms for neopronouns and neopronouns only? The fact is, the format that's used to state neopronouns seems to follow the format that the majority are using. So people are (now) saying (eg) "ey/em" and even "they/xe", even though the latter only gives one form of the neopronoun! Neopronouns are so uncommon that most don't know even the less obscure ones.
    – Laurel
    Commented Aug 28 at 16:33
0

Isn't it patently obvious that it would not be she/him/they? Or could it? Seems like one pronoun would be sufficient to get the message across. I have only seen she/hers/her. Haven't seen any men (is that ok to say?) doing it.

1
  • I have seen all of: he/him. he/him/his. he/they. they/he. (But yes, it is less common to see cis males specifying their pronouns, as "he/him" is already the assumed default for many people.)
    – arp
    Commented Aug 7, 2023 at 20:53
-2

There are badges and T-shirts on sale, each displaying the 3 forms of a pronoun, e.g. "she/her/hers". So that sort of set of 3 forms is what people display (those people who do that sort of thing), so that's what people see, so with positive feedback that's what's become popular.

Why those badges/T-shirts are made like that, I don't know -- that's a different question. It could be argued that another form, the -self form, should be included (e.g. himself, herself, xyrself). Then again, it could be argued that not only is that -self form needless, so is the -s form (e.g. hers).

2
  • Remember that there are not "three forms" to a personal pronoun; there are five. For example: I, me, my, mine, myself or they, them, their, theirs, themself.
    – tchrist
    Commented Feb 3, 2020 at 4:17
  • 1
    @tchrist I know. That's why I didn't say how many there are in total. The three forms I mentioned are the three the OP mentioned.
    – Rosie F
    Commented Feb 3, 2020 at 6:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .