1

If someone says “Tom broke another lamp,” does it imply that Tom already broke a lamp or that another lamp was previously broken by someone?

  • 7
    There is not enough context to answer your question. – Michael Owen Sartin Mar 26 '14 at 0:15
  • 1
    This is an interesting question that shows the importance of context in interpreting what seems to be a straightforward sentence. – anongoodnurse Mar 26 '14 at 0:36
  • 1
    Yes. Tom broke another lamp or another lamp was broken. – andy256 Mar 26 '14 at 0:51
  • 1
    I don't think ELU would have a bright future if we started welcoming questions of the general form "What does [some ambiguous construction] mean?". The reality is that every word, clause, or statement can have multiple meanings. I really see little point in questions where every answer would have to start with "The meaning depends on context" - if the user can't or won't supply enough context to at least potentially admit of a single, unambiguously correct answer, the question should be closed, not answered. – FumbleFingers Mar 26 '14 at 1:12
  • Sigh. Use the voting buttons folks. – andy256 Mar 26 '14 at 1:47
6

Depending on the context, it could mean either.

It looked like Tom finally had his clumsiness under control, but no. Tom broke another lamp.

Here it’s implied that Tom has broken lamps before (and perhaps other things too).

Dick and Harriet ran through the corridors, smashing light fixtures. Tom broke another lamp.

Here it’s clear that Tom is just one of several people breaking lights.


As Oldcat noted in a comment, another might even mean “different” instead of “additional”:

Tom didn’t break the lamp in the hall. Tom broke another lamp.

  • 6
    It could also mean that one light fixture in total was broken by Tom. But the one he broke was different from that named. "Did Tom break the lamp in the hall?" No, Tom broke another lamp. – Oldcat Mar 26 '14 at 0:28
  • 1
    @Oldcat Thank you for the excellent observation! I've incorporated it into the answer. – Bradd Szonye Mar 26 '14 at 0:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.