0

Is there a rule that states what word adjectives in a sentence will link to? If I say

I have a big cookie jar

it's still a correct sentence. The word "cookie" isn't an adjective, but "cookie jar" is a common term that represents a jar explicitly used to contain cookies.

In the phrases "dark green box" and "dark, green box" I know that with the comma, the box is dark and green, while without it, the box is dark green.

In the cookie jar sentence, is the jar explicitly used to contain "big cookies" or is the "cookie jar" big?

2

A sentence containing a noun with multiple modifiers would be confusing to read if there was not some common understanding regarding what modifies what.

Though it's not an absolute rule, the modifier closest to the main noun is most commonly presumed to modify that noun.

a big red silk hat is understood first and foremost as a silk hat, specifically a red one, and big in size, as one cannot modify red with big. A soft red silk hat, because soft usually doesn't modify red, would be understood as a soft silk hat which is red. One might avoid initial confusion in a bold red silk bear by hyphenating bold-red.

Similarly, a big cookie jar is understood to be, primarily, a cookie jar which is also big. A cookie jar for big cookies might be described as a wide-mouthed cookie jar just to avoid that potential ambiguity.

This is an interesting thread about adjectives.

2
  • Doesn't "mouth" also describe to opening of the jar? Couldn't the jar be wide-mouthed as in having a big opening? Also, the difference between the cookie jar sentence and the hat, box, and bear sentences is that "cookie" isn't an adjective, so the typical rules for adjectives might need to be modified. – Arc676 Feb 8 '14 at 13:51
  • @Arc676 - yes, that is the implication of a wide mouthed jar. Silk is not an adjective and more than cookie. Ther are exactly the same. :) – anongoodnurse Feb 8 '14 at 23:33
2

If the jar contained big cookies, it would be a big-cookie jar, not a big cookie jar. When there is no hyphen, the reader will assume that big and cookie are both modifiers of jar, because that is the default assumption to make.

2
  • True, but hyphens are often dropped when the intended meaning is also the most common or expected meaning, as in the example of "dark green box", where the most common interpretation is that dark modifies green; "dark-green box" would be acceptable, but generally not necessary. – AmeliaBR Feb 2 '14 at 17:25
  • ... Especially since a dark box that's light green seems impossible. – Edwin Ashworth Apr 10 '14 at 22:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.