0

"Around the time they first met, Daniel had told Mary Jane how toward the end of his parents’ lives—Daniel a late addition—his mother and father spoke only through the dog.> "

What does it mean "how toward the end of his parents' lives"?
Especially the meaning of "how toward"?

I've searched about the grammar of how, but all I could find was useless in this sentence.

Does it mean that " at the end of his parents' lives,his mother and father spoke only through the dog.considering the fact that Daniel was their last child"?

2
  • 1
    The OP's sentence comes from a fiction piece, "Marriage Quarantine", in the New Yorker. I think the "how" should have been set off with a dash or comma from the "toward".
    – DjinTonic
    Commented Dec 12, 2021 at 21:01
  • thank you very much. ^^
    – Hoda Di
    Commented Dec 13, 2021 at 19:11

2 Answers 2

1

It means that at the end of his parents' lives, his mother and father spoke only through the dog. See if reading it like this helps:

Around the time they first met, Daniel had told Mary Jane how—toward the end of his parents’ lives (Daniel being a late addition to the family)—his mother and father spoke only through the dog.

1
  • Thank you very much
    – Hoda Di
    Commented Dec 13, 2021 at 19:11
0

Your interpretation of this sentence's meaning is close, but I think that it's a bit off.

The nominal clause "how toward the end of his parents’ lives his mother and father spoke only through the dog" functions as the direct object of "told". It is introduced by the subordinating conjunction "how". It includes a subject ("his mother and father"), a simple predicate ("spoke"), and two adverbial prepositional phrases ("toward the end of his parents’ lives" and "only through the dog").

"Daniel a late addition" is an absolute nominal phrase. It is headed by "Daniel", which takes the appositive "a late addition".

I think that DjinTonic is suggesting that the prepositional phrase "toward the end of his parents’ lives" be surrounded by paired dashes or commas; this is often done to make such a phrase nonrestrictive or parenthetical:

Around the time they first met, Daniel had told Mary Jane how--toward the end of his parents’ lives--Daniel a late addition--his mother and father spoke only through the dog.

Around the time they first met, Daniel had told Mary Jane how, toward the end of his parents’ lives--Daniel a late addition--his mother and father spoke only through the dog.

Note that in either case, the pair's second mark gets absorbed into the dash after "lives".[1]

(By the way, I do not like the verb tenses in this sentence, but I'll keep quiet about that since you didn't ask about it.)

This is just one interpretation; I'm sure that others will analyze this sentence differently and use some different terminology.

[1] This is a bit of a simplification; I would actually consider "Daniel a late addition" to be a dependent of the preceding prepositional phrase, so that the new paired punctuation would really surround both.

1
  • 1
    thank you very much for the detailed explanation. It helped me a lot.
    – Hoda Di
    Commented Dec 13, 2021 at 19:09

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .