-1

Is this correct? "Since the last X years, Y is being used as ...". Meaning that Y has been used during the last X years, but also that it has been used for the first time only X years ago.

this seems incorrect: "Over the last X years, Y is being used as ...". "over" + passive present continuous feels weird for me.

And by using: "Over the past X years, Y have been used as ...", I think, would not have the same meaning as with "since".

Please, advice!

6
  • 3
    Since is wrong for your context. (Although that string of words could work in a different sentence: "Since the last 10 years have been wet, we expect the next few years to be drier.") Use "Over the last X years, Y was used" or "For the last X years, Y has been used"
    – Jim
    Commented Aug 6, 2015 at 23:27
  • I totally agree. Since cannot be used in the example you provided, user3416265.
    – sooeithdk
    Commented Aug 6, 2015 at 23:28
  • 2
    I agree with Jim's last version, "For the last X years, Y has been used". That is the natural sentence that a native speaker would use. Commented Aug 6, 2015 at 23:34
  • Thank you for the answer. Do you have any suggestion to replace the first part of the sentence, so that I can use passive present continuous next. "BLAHBLAH ..., Y is being used" I want to point out that Y is being used more and more starting from X years (in the past). "For the last X years" and "Over the last X years" seem not to convey this message. Thanks. Commented Aug 6, 2015 at 23:49
  • The use of Y has been increasing over the past X years.
    – Jim
    Commented Aug 6, 2015 at 23:55

2 Answers 2

2

I'd alter the statement to
"Since its introduction X years ago, Y has been used..."

Or, slightly restructured (as some people may feel more natural):
"Y has been used ... since its introduction X years ago."

(You could swap out "first use", "invention", "discovery", etc., instead of "introduction"...whatever you prefer.)

Alternatively, you could go with, "Starting X years ago, Y has been used..."

"Since" (in both preposition and conjunction roles) is more commonly paired with a singular event serving as the anchoring point of reference, and not a time period. "Since" already conveys the duration of time, and simply needs the starting/anchoring point (the event/date which happens to have been X years ago). So just provide the actual event/date (its first use, its invention, its discovery, Jan 1, 1983, etc.).

Per Dictionary.com:

Since

preposition

  1. continuously from or counting from:
    It has been warm since noon.

  2. between a past time or event and the present:
    There have been many changes since the war.

conjunction

  1. in the period following the time when:
    He has written once since he left.

  2. continuously from or counting from the time when:
    He has been busy since he came.

0

The usage of "since" has been an issue for many English learners, for the French, for example, since I know how its equivalent term in French is used. It often causes confusion among many other non-native speakers as well.

In the context in which it's been used here, "since" means "starting from", and needs a specific date, time or period.

Examples:

Since August 1
Since noon
Since the beginning of the 21st century

Therefore, one cannot say "since many years" or "since X years". In similar contexts, since is replaced by for.

Examples:

For (the last/past) ten years, I've been a vegetarian.
We haven't seen each other for almost a decade.
For the most part of 2014, the company made huge profits.

As for the usage of "over", we may say:

"We met over the weekend."
"Can we discuss this over lunch?"

It doesn't mean the same thing as "since", as in the above examples.

2
  • Thank you for the answer. Indeed I'm a native french speaker, and I was looking for the equivalent for "Depuis X ans" or "Depuis quelques années". Commented Aug 7, 2015 at 9:56
  • Oh, I thought so! Depuis dix ans = For (the last) ten years (now). Depuis quelques années = For several years (now).
    – Sankarane
    Commented Aug 7, 2015 at 17:36

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .