Skip to main content
copyedit
Source Link
tchrist
  • 137.3k
  • 49
  • 376
  • 609

'what about' “What about” vs 'what of'. ”what of”

Example from page 75 of Frederick Schauer’s Thinking Like a Lawyer:

But what of mandatory authorities? Are they as “binding” as the traditional terminology suggests? The answer depends on what is meant by “binding,” and it turns out that speaking of “binding” authority can be just as misleading as speaking of “persuasive” authority.

What are the similarities and differences between what about and what of? I see that the definitions below are worded differently, but don't perceiveI don’t see any intrinsic differences, which I still suspect tomust exist.

what about 1a. does that include (someone) : how about (someone)
1b. how does that affect (someone or something) :
2. used to make a suggestion about what could be done
3. used to ask someone to tell you something in response to the thing that you have just said

what of

  1. formal how does that affect (someone or something)
  2. why does (something) matter

Example from: P75, Frederick Schauer

But what of mandatory authorities? Are they as “binding” as the traditional terminology suggests? The answer depends on what is meant by “binding,” and it turns out that speaking of “binding” authority can be just as misleading as speaking of “persuasive” authority.

'what about' vs 'what of'

What are the similarities and differences? I see that the definitions below are worded differently, but don't perceive intrinsic differences, which I still suspect to exist.

what about 1a. does that include (someone) : how about (someone)
1b. how does that affect (someone or something) :
2. used to make a suggestion about what could be done
3. used to ask someone to tell you something in response to the thing that you have just said

what of

  1. formal how does that affect (someone or something)
  2. why does (something) matter

Example from: P75, Frederick Schauer

But what of mandatory authorities? Are they as “binding” as the traditional terminology suggests? The answer depends on what is meant by “binding,” and it turns out that speaking of “binding” authority can be just as misleading as speaking of “persuasive” authority.

“What about” vs. ”what of”

Example from page 75 of Frederick Schauer’s Thinking Like a Lawyer:

But what of mandatory authorities? Are they as “binding” as the traditional terminology suggests? The answer depends on what is meant by “binding,” and it turns out that speaking of “binding” authority can be just as misleading as speaking of “persuasive” authority.

What are the similarities and differences between what about and what of? I see that the definitions below are worded differently, but I don’t see any intrinsic differences which I still suspect must exist.

what about 1a. does that include (someone) : how about (someone)
1b. how does that affect (someone or something) :
2. used to make a suggestion about what could be done
3. used to ask someone to tell you something in response to the thing that you have just said

what of

  1. formal how does that affect (someone or something)
  2. why does (something) matter
edited tags
Link
tchrist
  • 137.3k
  • 49
  • 376
  • 609
Source Link
user50720
user50720

'what about' vs 'what of'

What are the similarities and differences? I see that the definitions below are worded differently, but don't perceive intrinsic differences, which I still suspect to exist.

what about 1a. does that include (someone) : how about (someone)
1b. how does that affect (someone or something) :
2. used to make a suggestion about what could be done
3. used to ask someone to tell you something in response to the thing that you have just said

what of

  1. formal how does that affect (someone or something)
  2. why does (something) matter

Example from: P75, Frederick Schauer

But what of mandatory authorities? Are they as “binding” as the traditional terminology suggests? The answer depends on what is meant by “binding,” and it turns out that speaking of “binding” authority can be just as misleading as speaking of “persuasive” authority.