Skip to main content
added 83 characters in body
Source Link
Araucaria - Him
  • 48.7k
  • 15
  • 113
  • 202

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we arewe know how expensive we are.

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

Changed title to match query
Link
Tinfoil Hat
  • 19.9k
  • 2
  • 23
  • 68

We are aware of our high cost Is "we know how expensive we are" an embedded question?

added 1 character in body
Source Link
KillingTime
  • 6.3k
  • 76
  • 35
  • 40

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

I cannot for the life of me decide if this is supposed to be interpreted as a complement clause or an embedded question or what.

My thought process so far is that it couldn't be a reported question (for semantic reasons) or fused relative ("how" here doesn't work as a relative pronoun) at all. Sources I've checked so far have been ambiguous about how small or vast a category "complement clause" can encompass, for example, with some including reported questions in the category of verbal complements (Mark Newson et al., 2006) and some not doing so.

Edit: I'll add the context in which the sentence originally appeared, after talking with my student. I believe this doesn't fundamentally change anything, but perhaps pushes it towards an interrogative interpretation:

You may complain about our high prices, but unlike a certain competitor, we have informed you that the increase would be 15%, so at least we know how expensive we are.

Source Link
Loading