Skip to main content
elaborated
Source Link
JEL
  • 33k
  • 4
  • 72
  • 111

The word that comes to mind is 'joy':

Intense and especially ecstatic or exultant happiness, or an instance of such feeling.

[joy. (n.d.) American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. (2011). Retrieved November 3 2015 from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/joy.]

'Joy', however, does not denote relief; rather it denotes enormous satisfaction and contentment. In this way, 'joy' is properly esthetic: it is a static emotion. As James Joyce expresses it in his "Paris Notebook",

... joy is excited by whatever is substantial or accidental [Yale MS. adds after "accidental", "general or fortuitous"] in human fortunes ...

(From James Joyce: The Critical Writings, edited by Ellsworth Mason and Richard Ellman, Viking, 1959.)

Later in the same paragraph, Joyce adds that

... even tragic art may be said to participate in the nature of comic art so far as the possession of a work of tragic art (a tragedy) excites in us the feeling of joy. ... All art, again, is static for the feelings of terror and pity on the one hand and joy on the other hand are feelings which arrest us.

(op. cit.)

In a note on the text of the latter passage, the editors point out that "Joyce substitutes stasis for catharsis. That joy may result from tragedy as well as from comedy does not follow well from what he has said. In the Portrait he confines the discussion almost completely to tragedy and changes 'joy' to 'the luminous silent stasis of aesthetic pleasure.'"

Aside from quibbles about whether the emotion occasioned by tragedy is, properly, joy, or rather the unadorned "stasis of aesthetic pleasure" (an overwrought expression more suited to the developing character of Stephen Dedalus in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man), it is the stasis of contentment or satisfaction whichthat constitutes such relief as may be felt in the apprehension of tragedy.

The word that comes to mind is 'joy':

Intense and especially ecstatic or exultant happiness, or an instance of such feeling.

[joy. (n.d.) American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. (2011). Retrieved November 3 2015 from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/joy.]

'Joy', however, does not denote relief; rather it denotes enormous satisfaction and contentment. In this way, 'joy' is properly esthetic: it is a static emotion. As James Joyce expresses it in his "Paris Notebook",

... joy is excited by whatever is substantial or accidental [Yale MS. adds after "accidental", "general or fortuitous"] in human fortunes ...

(From James Joyce: The Critical Writings, edited by Ellsworth Mason and Richard Ellman, Viking, 1959.)

Later in the same paragraph, Joyce adds that

... even tragic art may be said to participate in the nature of comic art so far as the possession of a work of tragic art (a tragedy) excites in us the feeling of joy. ... All art, again, is static for the feelings of terror and pity on the one hand and joy on the other hand are feelings which arrest us.

(op. cit.)

In a note on the text of the latter passage, the editors point out that "Joyce substitutes stasis for catharsis. That joy may result from tragedy as well as from comedy does not follow well from what he has said. In the Portrait he confines the discussion almost completely to tragedy and changes 'joy' to 'the luminous silent stasis of aesthetic pleasure.'"

Aside from quibbles about whether the emotion occasioned by tragedy is, properly, joy, or rather the unadorned "stasis of aesthetic pleasure", it is the stasis of contentment or satisfaction which constitutes relief in the apprehension of tragedy.

The word that comes to mind is 'joy':

Intense and especially ecstatic or exultant happiness, or an instance of such feeling.

[joy. (n.d.) American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. (2011). Retrieved November 3 2015 from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/joy.]

'Joy', however, does not denote relief; rather it denotes enormous satisfaction and contentment. In this way, 'joy' is properly esthetic: it is a static emotion. As James Joyce expresses it in his "Paris Notebook",

... joy is excited by whatever is substantial or accidental [Yale MS. adds after "accidental", "general or fortuitous"] in human fortunes ...

(From James Joyce: The Critical Writings, edited by Ellsworth Mason and Richard Ellman, Viking, 1959.)

Later in the same paragraph, Joyce adds that

... even tragic art may be said to participate in the nature of comic art so far as the possession of a work of tragic art (a tragedy) excites in us the feeling of joy. ... All art, again, is static for the feelings of terror and pity on the one hand and joy on the other hand are feelings which arrest us.

(op. cit.)

In a note on the text of the latter passage, the editors point out that "Joyce substitutes stasis for catharsis. That joy may result from tragedy as well as from comedy does not follow well from what he has said. In the Portrait he confines the discussion almost completely to tragedy and changes 'joy' to 'the luminous silent stasis of aesthetic pleasure.'"

Aside from quibbles about whether the emotion occasioned by tragedy is, properly, joy, or rather the unadorned "stasis of aesthetic pleasure" (an overwrought expression more suited to the developing character of Stephen Dedalus in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man), it is the stasis of contentment or satisfaction that constitutes such relief as may be felt in the apprehension of tragedy.

Source Link
JEL
  • 33k
  • 4
  • 72
  • 111

The word that comes to mind is 'joy':

Intense and especially ecstatic or exultant happiness, or an instance of such feeling.

[joy. (n.d.) American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. (2011). Retrieved November 3 2015 from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/joy.]

'Joy', however, does not denote relief; rather it denotes enormous satisfaction and contentment. In this way, 'joy' is properly esthetic: it is a static emotion. As James Joyce expresses it in his "Paris Notebook",

... joy is excited by whatever is substantial or accidental [Yale MS. adds after "accidental", "general or fortuitous"] in human fortunes ...

(From James Joyce: The Critical Writings, edited by Ellsworth Mason and Richard Ellman, Viking, 1959.)

Later in the same paragraph, Joyce adds that

... even tragic art may be said to participate in the nature of comic art so far as the possession of a work of tragic art (a tragedy) excites in us the feeling of joy. ... All art, again, is static for the feelings of terror and pity on the one hand and joy on the other hand are feelings which arrest us.

(op. cit.)

In a note on the text of the latter passage, the editors point out that "Joyce substitutes stasis for catharsis. That joy may result from tragedy as well as from comedy does not follow well from what he has said. In the Portrait he confines the discussion almost completely to tragedy and changes 'joy' to 'the luminous silent stasis of aesthetic pleasure.'"

Aside from quibbles about whether the emotion occasioned by tragedy is, properly, joy, or rather the unadorned "stasis of aesthetic pleasure", it is the stasis of contentment or satisfaction which constitutes relief in the apprehension of tragedy.