Although so-so means neither very good nor very bad, Merriam-Webster, it seemingly fits your tone and content, in that none were outstanding in any way. You could say ranged but you'd sound like a stiff using it as a single word.
The cookies produced were so-so.
The cliche, "varied reactions":
Jean received varied reactions when she went out in a tight fitting short skirt.
She also got "*assorted* looks".