My house is down the street.

Does the adverb down modify is, or street?

  • Up is not an adverb in this construction; it's a preposition, like up or on, and its object is the street. Most English words can be many parts of speech, so calling anything an adverb (or a noun, or verb, or adjective, etc.) is of no use in understanding grammar or usage. – John Lawler Dec 28 '12 at 22:35
  • 1
    @John Lawler: haha - the mere fact that you could address OP's hypothetical usage of "up" (rather than his actual "down") just goes to show how meaningless it is to speak of either word "modifying" anything in this exact context. Granted, it would make a difference if you lived on a hill - but we happily use both forms even where the street is perfectly level. – FumbleFingers Dec 28 '12 at 23:35

Down here is not an adverb but a preposition, heading the prepositional phrase down the street.

The PP as a whole acts as — well, now it gets tricky. The grammar I grew up with would have called it an adverb of location modifying is:

Where is the house? There. It's down the street.

But the older I get the less I like that. I'm inclined to say that the PP acts as an adjective of location modifying (actually, “predicated of”) house:

Which house? That house. The house down the street.

Which all goes to show how much more flexible the language is than the categories we use to describe it.

But in real life it's whatever your English teacher says it is.

  • Ah, I should have read this before I added the comment above, StoneyB. I agree with your analysis (keep getting older!) that there is no true adverbial behaviour here. I think one gets into trouble with mooting adjectival behaviour also: Is John here / home yet / down the road? John ran home / across the road. John died down the road. Though there are differences in adjectival - adverbial flavour, I tend to lump these as 'locative / directional (and some temporal) expressions'. dialnet.unirioja.es/descarga/articulo/1983827.pdf investigates the inadequacies of most classifications. – Edwin Ashworth Dec 28 '12 at 23:51
  • @EdwinAshworth: Where I come from, this use of what are normally attributive constituents is called predicative. So I would call it a predicative prepositional phrase. Similarly, I came first has a predicative adjective. This term is widely used. – Cerberus_Reinstate_Monica Dec 29 '12 at 4:03
  • I'm sorry, I'm not following you. Prepositional phrases are rarely used in an attributive position (when they are compound adjectives anyway). Down the road is syntactically replaceable by home or here in some expressions (John ran X; Is John X?) - the covering term locative / directional expressions works for me. – Edwin Ashworth Dec 29 '12 at 18:07

Neither. Down in this situation is a preposition, not an adverb. The complete phrase is "down the street". You can tell it doesn't modify either of the two words because it can't be separated from them:

My house is down.

My house is the street.

Neither makes sense.

  • "down the street," however, is an adverbial prepositional phrase modifying "is" – Nate Chandler Dec 28 '12 at 22:42
  • @NateChandler - Yes, quite true. – Lynn Dec 28 '12 at 22:43
  • 1
    I disagree. One really has to stretch the notion of modification (which admittedly some grammarians do) to allow 'down the street' to be a modifier of 'be / is' here. Surely a better analysis is one comparable to link-verb + complement: He is cold. He is here. He is down the street. The link-verb is a necessary grammatical device (admittedly showing tense); young children make do with John here etc (tense is now a difficulty). Intuitively, adverb(ial)s tell us something about the way the action of the verb is happening. Here / down the street tells us more about the house than any be-ing. – Edwin Ashworth Dec 28 '12 at 23:29

Adverbs cannot ever be used with copulas, as the copula essentially has no meaning and can be omitted, as it is in Russian and AAVE. A russian proverb: "Sex without love -- work." Usually the word "is" is used in the translation to English. Therefore the prepositional phrase is an adjective, as copulas are followed by a noun in the nominative, not the accusative, or by a descriptive adjective which directly modifies the subject of the verb, e.g., the sentence "John is green with envy and hates his brother now." could just as easily be "Green with envy, John hates his brother now.". Green modifies John. Same deal with "down the street".

You cannot "be" swimmingly, but you sure can "get along" swimmingly.

So to answer the question, the old-fashion way I was taught:

"Down" is not an adverb, and it does not modify anything. "Down the street" is a prepositional phrase used as an adjective, and it modifies "house". For example, look at "upon", which is never an adverb. My house is "upon the street" yonder. You can say someone sat "upon the witness seat", and that he's "going down" and end the sentence right there, meaning he's going to prison because of his crime, but you cannot say he's "sitting upon" unless you say upon what he is sitting. These phrases give the location, not destination, as in "going down to the 7-Eleven", an adverbial prepositional phrase. People speak of going "up to Denver", because it is north of Santa Fe, New Mexico, but also "down to Denver", because it is at a low altitude, only 5000 feet. In French Canada, everywhere is "l`a-bas" = "down there", and everything is "l`a", that is, "over there", even when immediately close at hand. I understand the chicken lips would say "ici", that is "y" = "there" plus "-ci" = here. People also talk of going down to places that are less important, up to places that are more important, or just use "down" to mean "over to". In Chamisal, New Mexico, people go "into town" or "up town" meaning north to Taos, or "downtown" meaning the much bigger city of Santa Fe, which is both south and larger and possessing a central area called "downtown". Taos does not have a downtown, because once you leave the central area, you are in open fields.

Rivers are the exception.

No one goes down the Nile and ends up in Ethiopia, even if it is south of Alexandria and reachable by water.

--Max Crane


"down the street" is a preposition group that is typically used after verbs of movement as in

  • He was slowly walking down the street. It is not so much a where or where-to indication but an indication of the way or direction.

Sometimes such preposition groups can be used after the linking verb to be as in

  • Greenwich is down the river.

I think one has to supplement "Greenwich is at a point that you reach when you go down the river" to understand the development of this use.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.