1

I would like to ask the postage department the questions like "how often the packages got lost in the mail" and "why the packages got lost in the mail".

While it is absolutely correct in Russian to "weld" such a questions together how can I do it in English? Is it correct to ask a question like this:

How often and why does this happen when the packages got lost in the mail?

4
  • Much simpler: "How often and why do packages get lost in the mail?" The construction with "happen" would be "How often and why does it happen that questions get lost in the mail." – StoneyB on hiatus Dec 24 '12 at 20:16
  • @StoneyB, for the construction with "happen", can you explain the grammatical rule by which “packages” gets changed to “questions”? – James Waldby - jwpat7 Dec 24 '12 at 20:40
  • @jwpat7 it's called the Slip Rule, after the famous Armenian neurologist Slip Freudian. – RegDwigнt Dec 24 '12 at 20:42
  • @jwpat7 What RegDwighт says; but it's a lexical rule, not a grammatical one. It operates only on Christmas Eve, and other days when I'm channeling Great-Uncle Slip. – StoneyB on hiatus Dec 24 '12 at 20:55
7

This is perfectly common in English, however the when should be a that. You are really combining "How often does it happen that X" and "Why does it happen that X". ("How often... when..." does not really make sense, after all.)

How often and why does it happen that packages get lost in the mail?

This works with other interrogatives, or a higher number of interrogatives, too — as long as you are combining sentences that only differ in the interrogative.

  • When, where, and by whom were you robbed?
    → works, combines "when were you robbed" with "where were you robbed" and "by whom were you robbed", which all make sense.
  • *When, where, and who robbed you?
    → doesn't work (that's what the asterisk means) because it combines "who robbed you" with "when robbed you" and "where robbed you", which are ungrammatical.

Here are a few example sentences from the Corpus of Contemporary American English:

  • When and why did they die out?
  • Where and when shall I meet you?
  • Who or what is Gumby?
  • Where, when and why do women take up horn?

(As a side note, there were a few other minor issues with your sentence that I fixed. The the is not justified because it makes it sound as if you were talking about the same packages being lost over and over again, while your intention is to ask about packages in general. The it can only be a this if you ask something like "How often and why does this happen?" and leave it at that. And the get can only be a got if you ask something like "How often did it happen that packages got lost".

Lastly, as StoneyB points out in his comment, you can lose the "does it happen that" part in favor of a simple "do". "How often and why do packages get lost?")

4

This is almost like factorising an algebraic expression.

Take your two questions and separate out the parts which are the same, and those which differ:

(How often)(do packages get lost in the mail)?
(Why)(do packages get lost in the mail)?

Then join the different parts to the bit which is the same:

(How often and why)(do packages get lost in the mail)?

to get the result.

How often and why do packages get lost in the mail?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.