4

I see this cropping up more frequently, particularly in legal discussions. My understanding was that OR included both logical clauses of AND and OR.

Has it become necessary to specify "and/or" vs. plainly "or"?

5

Natural languages are very vague about this.

You don't expect people to do both: Go swimming and playing video games after asking them "Do you want to swim or play video games?". So in this case, we are understanding an OR to be exclusive. But in a different context like "Do you want milk or sugar with your coffee?" you are considering the OR to be inclusive.

I don't think "and/or" is a good approach to differentiate an exclusive OR from an inclusive one. I think it's more intuitive to talk about "or" (inclusive) and "either or" (exclusive). I cannot answer this question regarding laws, because it might differ between countries and I am not into laws.

  • As you cite "natural languages": In German you would rather ask if someone would like "Milch und Zucker" ("milk and sugar") and expect the answer to specify the desired combination. "Oder" ("or") is always used to mean the XOR, the logical OR would feel weird. An answer to an "oder"-question including both options is possible, but also expresses the answerer's disagreement with the exclusiveness of the options. – I'm with Monica Sep 24 '12 at 13:21
2

As @ЯegDwight's comment and @meisterluk's answer tell you, speech is one thing, writing another—and context is everything!

As far as legal use goes: I haven't written for lawyers in thirty years, so i'm no longer aware of how much notice courts take of linguistic change.

But other things being equal, and/or is both lazy and graceless. Taking the trouble to say exactly what you do mean and exclude everything you don't mean is what lawyers get paid for, and shortcuts will eventually bite the practitioner in a sensitive part.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.