3

Are there some specific situations where one cannot replace the verb begin by commence? All English knowledge I have at the moment I've acquired on my own, and there are still a lot of questions to clarify.

3

Upon comparing some of the example sentences included in websters-dictionary-online.net definitions for begin and commence, I conclude that one usually can replace forms of the verb "to begin" by a comparable form of "to commence", but in many cases would not do so. Both verbs can be used in spatial or evaluative as well as temporal senses, but I think a form of "to begin" is more likely to be used than a form of "to commence" when sense is spatial or evaluative. For example:

The number one begins the sequence.
A terrible murder begins the novel.
The convocation ceremony officially begins the semester.

but

?The number one commences the sequence.
The sequence commences with the number one.
*A terrible murder commences the novel.
The novel commences with a terrible murder.
The convocation ceremony officially commences the semester.

  • 2
    Commence is nothing more than the Latinate for begin/start and it's a little more stilted. I can't even think of a time, off the top of my head, that I noted commence rather than begin or start unless I wanted to sound pretentious. – AnWulf Jun 3 '12 at 15:20
3

My entirely intuitive thought is that begin is less formal than commence. Dylan Thomas began his play for voices, ‘Under Milk Wood’, with the words ‘To begin at the beginning.’ He didn’t, with good reason, write ‘To commence at the commencement.’

  • Commencement ceremonies are usually school or college graduation ceremonies, I think, the stuff so full of pomp and circumstance. No wonder they use such a heavy-handed, academic word. – tchrist Jun 3 '12 at 20:21
  • One theatre I visit often has a set of recorded announcements that the show "will commence in n minutes". I have often wished that they would re-record these announcements in English. – Colin Fine Jun 3 '12 at 23:02
1

From the Merriam-Webster's Dictionary of Synonyms:

"Begin (implying opposition to end) and commence (implying opposition to conclude) are identical in meaning [emphasis mine - Alex B.]: the former is often preferred because less formal than the latter.

[...]

Traditional usage often supports the choice of commence in reference to court proceedings, religious or other ceremonies, or industrial, commercial, or military operations" (p. 94)

Burchfield, the editor of the third edition of Fowler's, is of the same opinion. There's a famous line in Fowler's on this:

"Families and neighbours are divided by the question of when to use commence and when to use begin."

The authors of the Merriam-Webster's Dictionary of English Usage concur that "you need not routinely change it [commence - Alex B.] to begin or start" (p. 264). They also mention that some people consider "commence" to be pretentious, old-fashioned, inappropriate, bookish, or pedantic. Some writers have used the word "commence" ironically - to make fun of toffs, e.g.

"... things never began with Mr. Borthrop Trumbull; they always commenced." George Eliot, as cited in Longman 1984

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.