9

For example, I found the following sentence written by a native English speaker (UK) so I'm going to assume that he knows how to put it the right way, although I wouldn't use this form.

I now have a bit more time to fix bugs etc but I'm open to offers if anyone wants to help maintain this module with me?

Is it correct or is the question mark misused here?

  • 3
    I have no doubt that it is? – Sven Yargs Jun 9 '17 at 4:05
4

In written speech this is a questionable usage. Nevertheless, when speaking, people frequently end declarative sentences with a rising intonation to invite the listener to consider the sentence as an invitation to agreement or action. One hears this kind of thing especially in the southern United States.

"Anyway, I had this Chrysler? It had a four-barrel carburetor?"

Here the speaker is making declarations about a car, but making them sound like questions so that the listener will respond (probably nodding or saying "uh-huh") in a way that indicates interest in and understanding of the story being related.

If your example sentence were spoken this way, listeners would likely interpret it as a request for help, not merely a statement of a condition. But if you write it, you should leave out the question mark.

Addendum

Since I wrote this, I've become aware that the practice of ending declarative sentences with a rising intonation actually has a name:

uptalk n
a manner of speaking in which declarative sentences are uttered with rising intonation at the end, as if they were questions.

  • 2
    I'm quite late to the conversation, but I must protest the generalization "if you write it, you should leave out the question mark." The syntax is probably questionable for formal writing, but formal writing isn't the only writing. The example given appears to be an email, which most people agree are largely (though not always) informal. – Hack Saw May 5 '11 at 21:46
  • 1
    I am aware of the phenomenon the OP mentions, and the phenomenon you are mentioning. I think they are different things. To my observation, the former appears at the end of a sentence, which in many cases a complex sentence. It seems to be asking an implicit question or assistance. The latter appears at the end of a phrase, which can be in the middle of a sentence, and it seeks for agreement. – sawa Nov 16 '17 at 11:00
  • Okay, I realize that Mr. Shiny and New 安宇's answer already mentions this. – sawa Nov 16 '17 at 11:05
11

While the sentence is not technically a question, the use of a question mark indicates that the speaker is inviting a response from others.

In that respect, the question mark conveys the speaker's meaning in a way that could not otherwise be indicated in writing without the use of additional words.

So I'd say that this use of the question mark is correct when recording informal speech like this - but formally, it should really be reserved for actual questions.

  • 1
    I would go one step further and say that if it wasn't an actual, if only implied, question, then the writer wouldn't have used the question mark. – aaronasterling Nov 26 '10 at 6:58
7

I now have a bit more time to fix bugs etc but I'm open to offers if anyone wants to help maintain this module with me?

This sentence/question is different than a statement and different than the "up-talking" that happens when people occasionally (or all the #$! time) raise the pitch of their sentences and phrases. If the person said

I now have a bit more time to fix bugs etc but I'm open to offers if anyone wants to help maintain this module with me.

they are merely stating that they have time and are open to offers for help.

By raising the pitch at then end (spoken) or adding the question mark (written) they are implying a question:

Would anyone like to offer to help me?

I hear this type of usage commonly.

We will proceed with the next item on the agenda, unless there are any questions? no? Ok, moving along...

3

This is something you see very often in spoken language.

As we talk, we are making a syntactic structure. It's common for syntactic structures to change, or be re-analyzed, as we go along. So in this case, "if anyone wants to help maintain this module with me?" is reanalyzed, on the fly, as "Does anyone want to help maintain this module with me?"

In careful writing, since readers can go back and check what you said previously, this sort of on the fly reanalysis is discouraged.

3

Just for the sake of anyone reading, I found this thread when I googled about this issue because Microsoft Word grammar checker tried to tell me that I should put a question mark at the end of this sentence: 'If you can do them in advance of this deadline then so much the better.'

I completely disagree with such a usage in written English.

  • I up-voted your statement and I would suggest you make a new question out of this, once you have the reputation to do so. – Nigel J Jan 17 '18 at 20:49
  • MS Word grammar checker flags up tons of perfectly acceptable constructions. This would seem to be a particularly extreme example, though. – peterG Jan 17 '18 at 23:37
2

Steve Melnikoff's is the best analysis, but can be taken further.

I think with the 'quick text parsing' that is becoming a part of our language pragmatics given the 'texting'/'information overload' age, punctuation marks in written materials are changing their purpose. As Melnikoff point out, in the example you use the question mark is inviting a response. The reader can visually 'skim' right through e.g., an email, to get at what his interlocutor wants him to respond to. The question mark is in effect basically an abbreviation with respect to what would have been written twenty years ago, when more verbiage would need to be required to have the request not come off in writing as rude.

English in the twenty-first century (in a particular context, at any rate).

0

Another example which I don't think quite fits any of the explanations above occurs in social media where the question mark is used at the end of declarative statements intended as accusations or harsh judgements. The context shows the statement to be actually declarative, though it could be considered an interrogative in other contexts. However, the poster doesn't want to come across as socially abrasive or intends to leave room for backing off of the judgement in case there is a backlash of disagreement or reverse judgement. For example:

"She is a narcissist?" "A guy that overweight shouldn't be going to McDonald's?" "Those so-called 'statues' are just toys for overgrown children?"

In this case it is a fundamentally disingenuous usage, because the poster clearly has a strong negative opinion about someone or some group, such that they want to express it, but don't feel either confident enough in themselves or the view to post it as a genuine declaration. Another way to put it would be as an unconvincing attempt at avoiding social liability.

-2

If a question is implied, the question mark should also be implied (i.e., not employed)!

Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.

  • 2
    I'm new here too still getting the hang of what is expected. Even when you are 100% sure of your answer, you will still get requests to provide some back up in the form of links and quotes. – S Conroy Aug 3 '18 at 16:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.