1

I was thinking about some late Beatles lyrics which were intentionally written to not make sense, but to create the illusion that there was hidden meaning to be discovered. This seems like the opposite of obfuscation, where you would take something meaningful and make it not make sense in order to hide the meaning.

Is there a word for this attempt at creating a false illusion of hidden meaning?

4
  • That's a very good question, thank you.
    – Ricky
    Feb 3 at 23:09
  • Can you give an example "of late Beatle lyrics that intentionally don't make any sense" as this will help people in formulsting answers. Feb 4 at 0:37
  • Few of the Beatles' lyrics ever make sense.
    – Ricky
    Feb 4 at 1:38
  • I think an example would probably be the song "I am the Walrus"
    – kaban teni
    May 12 at 17:08
3

mumbo jumbo

senseless or pretentious language, usually designed to obscure an issue, confuse a listener, or the like.

From a David Berlinski lecture:

" ... some banal thoughts buried in mathematical mumbo jumbo. Now, personally, I have nothing against mathematical mumbo jubmo: it's my stock-in-trade! But at the same time, let me tell you, I can recognize a co-conspirator."

https://www.dictionary.com/browse/mumbo-jumbo?s=t

1
  • I'm not sure mumbo jumbo fits, because although mumbo jumbo is designed to obscure an issue or confuse a listener, etc, that implies that there is an issue being obscured. I'm wondering more about when there is no issue--no meaning to be discovered--but the senseless or pretentious language is intended to imply that there is
    – kaban teni
    May 12 at 17:03
0

The word "illusion" already describes a false sense of reality. That is why magicians are said to do 'illusions' with their magic tricks. Another term might be mirage as in a desert mirage.

The Beatles songs are great because their lyrics combine wit, wisdom, fun, depth and transcendence like Lucy in the sky with diamonds walking the yellow marmalade road. This, together with the same for their music which had many moods and registers. They didn't follow fashion - but made it. And their songs remain timeless which is why they are, and will always be, perennial and evergreen favourites.

When their words don't make "sense" as you put it, this is because they were using their words as yet another musical instrument. After all, do musical instruments make "sense" as words? No, of course not. But this is because they resonate with the heart and not the head.

0

Pretentious fits. It means "to pretend". Though, people tend to only call things pretentious when it has failed at pretending so it has negative connotations associated with it which may not be what you're looking for if you're going to use a Beatles song as an example (or maybe you are? I guess it depends on whether you like the Beatles or hate them.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.