0

The word "broad" is pronounced /brɔːd/ (some US accents: /brɑːd/) instead of */brəʊd/. The spelling -OA- somehow suggests that these words are closely related and/or were pronounced the same at some point. In simple words, broad rhymes with caught, thought, sought and doesn't rhyme with BOAT, COAT, LOATH, ROAD, FOAM etc.

"Broad" is from Old English brād and its Old English pronunciation was /brɑːd/.

It seems that boat, road, loath, foam and broad had the same vowel sound /ɑː/ in Old English. All of them were spelled with ā and Wikitionary notes that their pronunciations were with /ɑː/ vowel. Why then is broad not pronounced the same as all those other words?

Edit

About a week ago I was reading a book on internet archive (whose name I have forgotten now and I am unable to find it again) which had an entry on "broad" and "abroad". I was lucky enough to take and save a screenshot from the entry. But I do not understand it well.

enter image description here

10
  • 4
    The major reasons are (1) that not all sound changes occur without exceptions. And (2) that English spelling does not represent the sounds of Modern English. – John Lawler Feb 3 at 14:53
  • @JohnLawler That's utterly true! English spelling doesn't make sense but I'm sure someone here knows why it happened and that's what I'm interested in knowing. ;-) – Sphinx Feb 3 at 14:56
  • 2
    I would disagree that most Americans have the FATHER vowel in broad instead of the THOUGHT vowel. That would sound bizarre, and you'd notice it right off the bat sticking out like a sore thumb. – tchrist Feb 3 at 14:57
  • @tchrist I dont know but Cambridge English dictionary only lists the FATHER vowel for most words in American English. I'll edit it. – Sphinx Feb 3 at 14:58
  • 2
    @Sphinx They're making things up because their sample size of N=1 is some junior high school kid from West Hollywood. Most of the country doesn't speak that way, but Hollywood has an outsized representation in foreigners' perceptions. – tchrist Feb 3 at 15:00
1

The pronunciation of broad with /ɔː/ instead of /əʊ/ is exceptional. Most words spelled with oa followed by a letter other than "r" are pronounced with /əʊ/ (/oʊ/ in American English), which developed regularly from Middle English /ɔː/. A previous question asking whether there are any similar examples of oa being pronounced /ɔː/ turned up no similar words: Is the pronunciation of "oa" in "broad" unique?

There is not a clear reason for broad not being pronounced /brəʊd/. As the extract you quote mentions, it is possible that the use of /ɔː/ is related to the r in this word, but that's not a perfect explanation because there are other words with r such as road, broke, groan that have /əʊ/ and not /ɔː/ in modern English.

Great, break, steak are similar exceptions to the usual development of /iː/ in words with the Middle English vowel [ɛː] and the modern English spelling pattern -ea-.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.