1

Consider the sentence:

Our son, John, is 15 and our daughter, Mary, 11.

Is it grammatical? I have read such omission of the linking verb (especially is) in a sentence with a compound subject. I wanted to know if the linking verb attaches to both the subjects. Is the above preferred to the more straightforward (and grammatical) construction:

Our son, John, is 15 and our daughter, Mary, is 11.

?

5
  • 1
    I haven't downvoted, but I think the downvoter probably wanted you to ask your question on English Language Learners. – Decapitated Soul Jan 18 at 15:48
  • I see. I think we are all learning this great language, aren't we? And one were to go by answers to this question, it hardly feels like a question not appropriate for this SE. – Kedar Mhaswade Jan 18 at 17:35
  • And why use -1 to indicate a probable move to another SE? Is that what meta SE asks us to do? If true, that's quite unfortunate, @DecapitatedSoul! (I know you are just helping and you are not the downvoter; but this makes me sad :-( ). – Kedar Mhaswade Jan 19 at 2:25
  • I've counteracted the downvote. Downvotes just mean that someone disagrees with your question. – Decapitated Soul Jan 19 at 4:28
  • Casting a bare downvote (the one without any justification) is easy, just click on the arrow! That ease, I believe, makes people -- even seasoned SEers -- sloppy. It also promotes speculation among others. Some people take it personally (like what I may be perceived as doing here). Maybe SE should abandon casting bare downvotes. If, on the other hand, any justification is provided, the downvote could be accepted. I know, all of this might be already discussed somewhere ... – Kedar Mhaswade Jan 19 at 11:19
2

Our son, John, is 15 and our daughter, Mary, __ 11.

Yes: it's grammatical.

This is called 'gapped coordination' (or 'gapping'), which occurs when the middle part of a non-initial coordinate is omitted but recoverable from the corresponding part of the first coordinate.

The gap marked __ is understood by reference to the first coordinate, in this case "is".

I prefer the version without gapping, especially in speech, but usage varies.

Edit: Here's a link to Wiki's article on gapping link

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.