0

As a Redditor pointed out, using a demonym that ends in '-ese' as a noun sounds incorrect or at least awkward (especially a singular noun--someone on the thread writes, 'For example you could say “I met a Chilean” but not “I met a Chinese.”').

Most of the countries with '-ese' demonyms seem to be in East Asia, and hence perhaps people in English-speaking countries didn't have much occasion to talk about people from them until relatively recently. (The exception might be the giant country of China, for which there was a separate nounal demonym that is now considered a slur.) That might explain why there is no natural-sounding way to refer to 'a Japanese', 'a Vietnamese', etc. But what about countries that have been known to English-speaking peoples for a very long time, e.g., Portugal, or the city of Vienna (or perhaps Malta)? Did earlier English speakers have another way of referring to an individual from Portugal or Vienna (or anywhere else I might have missed) other than 'a Portuguese' or 'a Viennese', and if so, what was it? (And, out of curiosity, was there ever a separate nounal demonym for, say, Japan, or Burma, in the Victorian period, like there was for China?)

1
  • 1
    Merriam-Webster online doesn't mark the noun usage of Chinese as offensive, derogatory, obsolete, or otherwise indicate they think it's gone out of use. Although I agree that it does sound dated and/or derogatory, this development is really pretty recent.
    – The Photon
    Jul 20 '20 at 21:21
1

The denonym was Japanese, Portuguese, Javanese, and so forth. (Although Burman is also attested for a native of Burma.) In the 18th century and earlier, these were at least sometimes pluralized as Japaneses, Portugueses, and Javaneses.

The OED has

Portuguese A1. A native or inhabitant of Portugal; a person of Portuguese descent.
1622 T. Robinson Anat. Eng. Nunnery Diuers Portugeses our neighbours.
1835 J. E. Alexander Sketches in Portugal I saw only one countryman, a cut-throat looking fellow.., chained to a Portuguese, and carrying sand for paviers.

Japanese B1. A native of Japan.
1604 E. Grimeston tr. J. de Acosta Nat. & Morall Hist. Indies A Iapponois reported this after hee was christened.

Javanese B1. A native of Java (formerly with plural Javaneses).
1704 tr. P. Baldæus Descr. Ceylon in A. Churchill & J. Churchill Coll. Voy. III. The Javaneses and Mardykers.

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.