0

Example:

From the movie Kingdom of Heaven

Balian of Ibelin: What is Jerusalem worth?

Saladin: Nothing. ... Everything!

What lesson did Saladin teach Balien? _____

Balian returned to Europe reflecting on this lesson of _____ that Saladin taught him. How hundreds of years of religious wars over a piece of land and hundreds of thousands of deaths can be seen as _____ .

What I thought of:

From my understanding this is the juxtaposition between Jerusalem being worthless desert and great spiritual significance to religion at same time.

Is the lesson he learnt transcendence perhaps?

9
  • Related: Relationship between Juxtaposition, Oxymoron, and Paradox. Commented Jul 19, 2020 at 11:27
  • A matter of perspective. Commented Jul 19, 2020 at 13:49
  • @JasonBassford What is salt worth or spices worth. It all depends on supply and demand. it depends what you are going to use it for. So, the word perspective doesn't really fit. It is one person that knows it has two worth rather than two different people with differing perspectives. This scene is the moral of the movie. The moral 100s of years of wars. The quote by one of the greatest leaders. The epiphany moment that a place can have multiple worth. I need a word that can convey this.
    – greay
    Commented Jul 20, 2020 at 9:52
  • 2
    What lesson did Saladin teach Balien? [What did Balien see Saladin exemplifying?] If Saladin rather quickly re-assessed, either vacillation or flexibility. If he recognised the fact that perspective was key and chose to use an oxymoron, paradox (and a need for open-mindedness). Commented Jul 20, 2020 at 11:20
  • 1
    One man’s junk is another man’s treasure.
    – Jim
    Commented Jul 20, 2020 at 14:49

3 Answers 3

2

Worth two things at the same time is a Duality. See bottom paragraph. In this case Duality of value.

Perspective is a good word that may describe Saladin's view but not his experience. It must have been near the climax of the film to ask such a profound question. The lesson must be profound or you have wasted your ninety minutes. If we can't entertain words for such profundities we can't very well boast of our literacy.

By "Nothing and everything." he is telling us his experience of Jerusalem. The two extremes coming together make an important duality, such as the definition of God as 'an infinite sphere, whose centre is everywhere and whose circumference is nowhere'.

In this case his experience has been seeing friends struggle and die for the advantage of a few extra square feet of territory that's just like any patch of dirt one hundred miles in any direction. Like so many things of purported value it may not turn out to be worth what it actually cost you. You find that out after you see what you can really do with it once you've got it.

I think the right term would start from the original question of "What is it worth?" The answer should be Value. The meaning behind the answer, Value, would be as loaded and open to interpretation as any other you could think of. It would remind the victory minded of their great glory and the more sober minded of their terrible cost. The range of these answers bring forth the duality.

Your thoughts are interesting but the word juxtaposition makes me think of the meaning switching from one to another; only one at a time. What Jerusalem means is both and at the very same time. Both the worthless desert and its great spiritual significance to religion. The duality is vital to its true value.

2
  • A duality does not mean something is worth two things at the same time.
    – Lambie
    Commented Jul 21, 2020 at 16:20
  • 1
    @Lambie, You're right, it doesn't. It means is two things at the same time. That is why I had to add the word Value to the term to get it across; Duality of Value.
    – Elliot
    Commented Jul 22, 2020 at 0:32
1

He taught him humility. Doesn't all this religious stuff boil down to that? But in terms of two opposites: the lesson of things not always being what they seem.

That is, reality is paradoxical, a paradox.

two opposite situations: worthless dessert/great spiritual significance

Paradox: Merriam Webster:

c: an argument that apparently derives self-contradictory conclusions by valid deduction from acceptable premises

this lesson on paradox

0

Ambivalence: the state of having two opposing feelings at the same time, or being uncertain about how you feel (dictionary.cambridge.org)

My gut feeling is that this word doesn't fit in your example as well as the one suggested by Elliot, but I have to include it because its etymology so perfectly fits your question.

The above definition describes a state of the beholder in whose eye beauty so famously resides. A deeper discussion of value is beyond this post, and Elliot addressed it well already; suffice it to say that the true value of something could be argued to be independent of someone's perception of its value. One place to start that discussion is at https://www.britannica.com/topic/gold-standard.

OP's comment showing the other side of the coin should be saved in relation to this discussion, too, so I quote it here just in case: "What is salt worth or spices worth. It all depends on supply and demand. it depends what you are going to use it for."[sic] --greay

An entry at etymonline says it comes through German, contrary to what I previously assumed: that it came directly from Latin "two values":

"simultaneous conflicting feelings," 1924 (1912 as ambivalency), from German Ambivalenz, coined 1910 by Swiss psychologist Eugen Bleuler on model of German Equivalenz "equivalence," etc., from Latin ambi- "both, on both sides" (see ambi-) + valentia "strength," abstract noun from present participle of valere "be strong" (from PIE root *wal- "to be strong"). A psychological term that by 1929 had taken on a broader literary and general sense.

So you could say that Saladin sees "two strengths" of Jerusalem.

Related: Is there a single word for "Evoking Ambivalence"? (special mention: both OP and Patrick's answer)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.