0

"If this work could be discovered, it might, he thought, in all probability be restored. Some of the country people were therefore seized, and, inquiry being made of them, the line of the canal was pointed out, and the place shown at which it had been derived from the Nahr-Malcha."

  • Welcome to Writing.SE! If you're asking about whether someone else's writing is grammatically correct, then this question belongs on English.SE. This site is for asking for assistance with your own writing. – F1Krazy Jul 3 at 14:30
  • 2
    Please don't ask the same question on multiple Stack Exchange sites. Had I known you'd done that, I would have just voted to close the one on Writing.SE instead of migrating it here. I suppose part of the blame's on me for not checking first, but I've now flagged this to be closed as a duplicate of the first version of the question. – F1Krazy Jul 3 at 18:30
0

The exclusion of "was" is actually an example of Gapping, a form of Elliptical Construction. Ellipsis is almost, but not quite, the opposite of Parallelism; Ellipsis means leaving out duplicated information, while Parallelism is about deliberately adding in duplication for emphasis.

It is possible that you may be inferring Parallelism from the use of both "pointed out" and "shown" - these are both phrases with similar meanings, and can be used for Parallelism. However, they are not being used here to support a common noun/verb, to provide synonymous expression of similar concepts, nor even to contrast antithesis. It also doesn't help that the second clause ("the place shown at which it had been derived from the Nahr-Malcha") contains a lengthy restrictive clause following the verb. All you have here is a list of information gathered from the questioning.

You could adjust the sentence to invoke more parallelism, by connecting both concepts to a single verb ("...and, inquiry being made of them, they pointed out the line of the canal, and the place at which it had been derived from the Nahr-Malcha"), but the excessive length of the second phrase makes this weak Parallelism

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.