0

According to Garner's fourth edition,

'd have liked to should be followed by a present-tense infinitive, so 'd have liked to (٭have done) is wrong; nor is correct 'd like to have done because the sequence of events is then off.

What does the author mean exactly by the sequence of events is then off?

1
  • 1
    Is that a direct quote, word-for-word, from Garner? The phrase "nor is it correct 'd like to have done" doesn't sound like American (or British) English to me. – chasly - supports Monica Jun 23 '20 at 21:52
2

As I understand the sentence quoted, I disagree with the author.

All the versions are valid and have different meanings.

Examples

  1. I would have liked to see Australia.

When I was younger, to see Australia is what I would have liked. Now that I'm older, it isn't what I would like because I don't like long plane journeys.


  1. I would like to have seen Australia.

I would like now to have seen Australia in the past.


  1. I would have liked to have seen Australia.

My memory is failing but I'm pretty sure that, when I was 30, I would at that time have liked to have seen Australia when I was 20.


In real life, people don't make these distinctions and you will hear all three versions. What people usually mean is, "I wish I'd visited Australia when I was younger"

3
  • What about I'd have liked to have done it vs_ I'd like to have done it_? – GJC Jun 23 '20 at 22:43
  • @GJC - That's the same as cases 1 and 3 in my answer. "I'd" in this context is a contraction of "I would". In other contexts "I'd can be a contraction of "I had" That is another distinction the text-book doesn't seem to make. Don't worry too much about this. IRL speakers tend to use 1 or 2 and probably don't know that there is a difference. – chasly - supports Monica Jun 23 '20 at 23:20
  • @GJC - I suggest that you pick "I'd have liked to...". This what Garner suggests and it's a safe option even if his reasoning is suspect (in my opinion) – chasly - supports Monica Jun 23 '20 at 23:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.