2

Would it be incorrect to say 'a school' of whales?

4

It seems that it was almost universally a school of whales until around 1930: see this Ngram; school is still used quite frequently. Note that pod is also currently used for dolphins.

I assume that the reason that school of whales is being replaced by pod of whales is that nowadays people are more aware of the fact that whales are not fish, and this wording emphasizes it. But an interesting questions remain: what is the origin of pod as a collective noun for dolphins and whales? The earliest usage I find in Google books is from 1836. In this reference, a pod of whales is a smaller subgroup within a school of whales.

And now the captain is in full chase of the school when, perceiving a pod of whales in the rear of the school, which seemed to lie more quiet than the main body, he bore down upon them with oar and sail.

And an 1837 reference explains the distinction more clearly,

Spermaceti Whales are gregarious, and are met with in what are called schools, or pods. The former consist of from twenty to fifty, being principally females with their young, guarded in the rear by a male of the largest size, who takes up a defensive position, and, when pursued by boats, urges the others to move quicker, by attacking them. A pod consists of eight or ten, generally young ones.

  • Until 1930? But Hemingway said in his famous novel 'the Old Man and the Sea 'a school of porpoises'; he used the term with dolphins too. Was he wrong? – user15851 Jan 1 '12 at 16:49
  • He wasn't wrong. From the Ngram, school seems to have been the most-used term for both dolphins and whales until the 1990s. Before 1930 or so, Google Ngrams shows that school was almost universally used. In the 1930s, pod starts increasing in use, but it does not overtake school until the 1990s. I'm editing my answer to be clearer. – Peter Shor Jan 1 '12 at 16:57
  • I based my reply in the comment on your answer not the Ngram. Hemingway's novel was published in the 1950s that's why I raised the question. Thanks for answering. – user15851 Jan 1 '12 at 17:12
3

As @Peter Shor says, school of whales was the standard form until recently. Quite possibly still is, though if the current trend continues pod will probably become the more common term very soon.

It's misleading to ask which form is "correct". There are many different types of whales - a group of killer whales (orca) is often called a pack, and sperm whales (their prey) still often come in herds.

In the age of wildlife documentaries, we're all far more accustomed to seeing marine life in its natural social groupings, so the non-specialist has much more reason to refer to them. Unlike seal-hunters, we don't like to refer to their livelihood as "herds", so "herd of seals" is declining.

As has often been pointed out here on ELU, there is no special committee for English telling us what words we should use, and where. The usage of "pod" has been widely adopted for the whole social group, although it originally meant a consistently-maintained sub-group within that whole. This doesn't make the new usage "wrong" - if enough of people say it, it's by definition acceptable.

-1

I am very thankful for this clear and well structured answer. I was always taught that a group of dolphins or whales was a

school /sku:l/.

A group of fish is a

shoal /Sheul/.

These terms are quite distinct and I do not understand why they should be confused and then to have some people then decide that the only correct term for a group of cetaceans is a pod when as this answer makes it clear that the pod originally referred only to a smaller subgroup of a school.

  • Welcome to EL&U! This seems like a great answer, but could you improve it by adding references to sources such as a dictionary proving the collective nouns? – BladorthinTheGrey Sep 18 '16 at 12:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy