0

I still don't seem to fully understand the difference between these three:

I've been exposed to English as a kid

I'd been exposed to English as a kid

I was exposed to English as a kid

Could someone explain how they are different and which one I should use in this specific context?

From what I know, the first sentence makes no sense unless you are still a kid, and the second and the third sentences are both correct but the former is preferred in the UK.

  • I'm in the UK and I'd use "I was exposed..." in this case. – KillingTime Mar 1 '20 at 11:02
0

"I've been exposed to English as a kid" is a grammatical incongruence as present perfect can only be used when there are no time indications that the action is in the past and no longer ongoing. Since "as a kid" clearly is such an indication, the first sentence is grammatically unaccepatable.

"I'd been exposed to English as a kid" requires some sort of "when something else happened" "before somene did something", where the tense of the "when clause" is simple past. It is used to express anteriority (something takes place before something else) e.g. "I'd already been exposed to English as a kid before I met my American cousins, so I could understand them even though I could not speak their language competently"

"I was exposed to English as a kid" is what an adult is likely to say to express that when they were children people around them spoke English and adressed them in English. Simple Past (in the passive form in this instance) to express that "all that" (i.e. the action expressed by the verb) is in the past and it no longer affects the present.

  • I see now, thanks a lot. So you can't use Past Perfect in this context without a "when clause", huh. I didn't know about that. Thanks once again. – displayname11 Mar 1 '20 at 11:40
  • Even though the "when clause" might only be inplicit in the context of the conversation and not be uttered by the speaker. – AlecBowden Mar 1 '20 at 11:57
  • Yes, naturally. – displayname11 Mar 1 '20 at 12:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.