Yet climbing Ayers Rock, as most other Australians knew the vast red monolith until recently, has long been a favoured pastime of tourists.

Is it better to use "which "instead of "as "in "as other australians knew..."

enter image description here

  • No, because the sentence would need another "as" further along. "Yet climbing Ayers Rock, which most other Australians knew the vast red monolith as until recently, has long been a favoured pastime of tourists. " – Weather Vane Oct 29 '19 at 14:00
  • Further, "as" is not a relative word, though it may function in a very similar way in such comparative constructions. – BillJ Oct 29 '19 at 14:09
  • AS looks like a coordinating conjunction, like IF, BECAUSE, AND, BUT etc. E.g. As she came in, the man went out. In usages like SUCH...AS, SO...AS, etc., it functions as correlative conjunction. The man is so strong as his rival. He is such an arrogant as one can see in an uncivilized society. – Ram Pillai Oct 29 '19 at 14:36
  • Please give Fowler due respect (an attributed link). / " 'Bernie', as most people know him ..." shows a very common usage of 'as' that Fowler seems to miss. – Edwin Ashworth Oct 29 '19 at 14:37
  • "As" is a preposition, not a relative word. The comparative expressions it introduces are semantically very similar to relatives, but they differ syntactically. – BillJ Oct 29 '19 at 15:46

Nonrestrictive "as"

Understand the answer by understanding the function of the clause... This is known as "nonrestrictive", as opposed to "restrictive".

From K-12 Reader: emphasis added

A nonrestrictive clause (also known as a nonessential clause) is a type of adjective clause that provides additional information about a word whose meaning is already clear. A nonrestrictive clause often begins with the word which and are always set off with commas.

...Notice it says that "which" often begins the clause, but it doesn't always have to...

For clarity, this is the clause from your question:

, as most other Australians knew the vast red monolith until recently,

So, you are adding additional information that informs the reader, but is not required to distinguish one thing from another.

That leads us to connotation:

the associated or secondary meaning of a word or expression in addition to its explicit or primary meaning

Both "which" and "as" are acceptable. I personally prefer "as" because of the connotative feeling I get with it.

By using "which", it would feel like you are going to a kind of boring lecture mode, perhaps. But, "as" is more soft and conversational, open to other ideas, and isn't as heavy-handed. By using "as", this is still a nonrestrictive clause, but it doesn't feel as boring as one...

...as some may agree. (See what I did there?)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.