I was reading about the origin of the @ symbol. It came on the scene in 1531. It has always meant “at” for pricing. New usages have been assigned to it as well as using “at” as a preposition, e.g.

"person at mail server gmail in top level domain com".

And of course twitter has cemented @ as also meaning “person”.

@person thanks for the meatloaf.

So I was thinking @ in a commercial context seems like a replacement for multiply. Or “x”. So I tried it out and wrote equivalent expressions.

A) 5 apples at $3.99 each

B) 5 apples times $3.99 each

It struck me that in A) at sounds more like an adjective. And in B) times or multiply sounds more like a verb. It also sounds like a command as in “do multiply and tell me the answer” but that must be from schooling.

Is @ an adjective? What about 'times'?

  • 1
    Is 'so' consequential so or non-sequiturial so? // (A) 'at' introduces the prepositional phrase (at $3.99 each), which, as 'of the highest quality', is an adjectival post-modifier. (B) '5 apples @ $3.99 each = $19.95' uses @ [...each] in place of 'times', which is notoriously fickle as regards POS. Oct 21, 2019 at 16:02


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.