-1

"It was an April afternoon. And the warm breezes of approaching summer had sent everyone, including Grandfather, indoors".

The above sentences are from the story 'Adventures in a Banyan Tree' by the Indian English writer Ruskin Bond. (The context of the story is a school boy's summer vacation excitements and experiences, which he narrates after the vacation. The summer vacation falls in April and May)

Based on these sentences, a question for editing came in an examination. But in the question, they used only "April" instead of "April afternoon" as shown below:

"It was (a) at April. The warm breeze of the approaching summer (b) have sent everyone indoors including grandfather".

Now my question is about the answer to (a): can it be an as in the actual sentence in the story?

Or,

Should it be in, the preposition before the name of a month?

[This question I asked on ELL a little while ago and I got an answer there. But the answer does not clear my doubt whether I can use in or not, as in It was in April.]

If the sentence were something like It was in April (a strange thing happened.), wouldn't it grammatically be an acceptable sentence?

closed as off-topic by Jason Bassford, marcellothearcane, Cascabel, Reinstate Monica, David Sep 11 at 12:27

  • This question does not appear to be about English language and usage within the scope defined in the help center.
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 1
    It was April. It was an April afternoon. It was in April. All standard, all have different meanings. – Lambie Aug 29 at 14:43
  • @Lambie, Sir, is it okay if I edit the exam question (a) as It was in April ? – mahmud koya Aug 29 at 14:46
  • 1
    It was in April. The exam was in April. The event was in April, not May. Etc. etc. But: It was an April afternoon. [no sir please. :)] – Lambie Aug 29 at 15:43
  • 1
    In the quotation the phrase is "an April afternoon", in this "afternoon" is a noun modified by "April" which is being used as an adjective showing that the afternoon was in April. In the editing question the word "afternoon" is omitted so "April" is used as a noun but the preposition used with it is "at" which is not used for months, days or years but only for specific times such as "midnight" or "eight minutes past one". The correct preposition for use with months is "in" which is the answer to question a . Also the answer to b is "had" as breeze is singular and "have" is plural. – BoldBen Aug 29 at 23:14
  • 4
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic. You've already stated you asked the same question at ELL (where you accepted an answer to it). If you meant to ask a different question here, you need to rephrase the question to remove all of the extraneous pieces that you already accepted elsewhere. Otherwise, the same question can keep getting answered on the two different sites. – Jason Bassford Aug 29 at 23:56
0

I think all options are permissible but not equally desirable. It depends on personal preference and style. The most common usage would be "It was April". This contrasts April with other months i.e. it wasn't May. "It was an April" suggests maybe that the writer can't remember which April it was. Doesn't necessarily seem wrong to me but contains an element of redundancy. "It was in April" emphasises that the event happened in April but would often be followed by "that" as in "It was in April that this event happened".

I would choose "It was April" as the answer.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.