0

There exist some statements that become untrue simple because someone has said them publicly. A conceptual example might be I have never said the word: contumacious. A more realistic example might be 0QlmIfMjYFLUrCtBT8qd is a secure password.

These kinds of statements are probably not common, but is there any single word or phrase that can be used to describe them?

  • No, there is no such single word (nor concise phrase), precisely because that kind of statement is uncommon. – High Performance Mark Aug 26 at 13:32
  • 1
    @HighPerformanceMark: Uncommon, but not unknown. Google Books has a few people saying I never fucking swear. – FumbleFingers Aug 26 at 13:49
  • Strictly speaking, sentences (which are governed by grammar, not logic) have no truth value. Truth values are a property of propositions, in logic, which is not governed by grammar, but by axioms. Furthermore, propositions don't exist in time, so they can't become true or false; they are either true or false. If you add time and change you don't have logic any more. – John Lawler Aug 26 at 14:49
  • "I'm not speaking" does it count? I am saying I am not speaking but while I say that I actually do. – ozgur Aug 26 at 18:48
  • This is an index of all books that don't index themselves. Depending on how you look at it, the sentence is nonsensical, paradoxical, ambiguous, undefined, true, or false—or all or none of those things. This is really more a question of philosophy than English. (The examples in the question are more specific, but still of the same disputable type—with the meaning shifting depending on your contextual framework.) – Jason Bassford Supports Monica Aug 27 at 4:15
1

Such statements are called self-defeating.

Self-refuting ideas or self-defeating ideas are ideas or statements whose falsehood is a logical consequence of the act or situation of holding them to be true. - wikipedia

A more general concept is defeasibility, where a defeasor 'defeats' a position (not necessarily its own). This is formalised in defeasible logic.

  • I don't think this matches the description exactly as I'm thinking more specifically of something that becomes untrue because it's said aloud rather than because of the idea itself, but it's close enough. Thanks! – Duck Hunt Duo Aug 27 at 7:41
  • @DuckHuntDuo I added a bit extra, but the answer I’m proposing is really just the first line. Do you disagree that your example statements are examples of self-defeating statements? – Lawrence Aug 27 at 10:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.