0

I am new here and I am beginner in English. Can anyone explain me the difference between these 2 sentences and also which one is wrong.

"Did you see my DP?"

or

"Have you seen my DP?"

Please explain me the Answer and which one is right and why?

marked as duplicate by Cascabel, jimm101, Edwin Ashworth, Lawrence, Janus Bahs Jacquet Jun 25 at 16:11

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • 1
    Neither one is wrong. Both are in use.The first is past tense , and the second is a perfect construction and possibly more formal.. – Cascabel Jun 25 at 14:32
  • Could you explain which sentence we use for writing and which one for speaking – Gurinder Batth Jun 25 at 14:35
  • 1
    Well, you wouldn't exactly use this type of question in writing, unless maybe in texting...and that is usually informal. So if you are really asking when to use past and perfect, you will need a better example. ..but your post is possibly too broad, and without doubt has been asked here before many times. – Cascabel Jun 25 at 15:06
  • @Cascabel could you help me ? Please – Gurinder Batth Jun 25 at 15:09
0

Both "Did you see my DP?" and "Have you seen my DP?" are correct for written as well as oral conversations.

But if you want to know the difference between Did and Have, then here it is:

Did you see is used only for the Past Indefinite/Simple Tense. (Like we used 'see' which is in simple tense with 'did'). It works for works for recent past till now.

Have you seen is used in the Present Perfect Tense. (Like we used 'seen' which is in present perfect tense with 'have'). It works for anything that still applies from any time till the present, thus emphasises on the present.

For example:

Did you see the new movie? (A movie once released can be seen any time. So it can be past or present both.)

Have you seen the new episode? (A TV episode airs only on a particular day, so it's something very close to present.)

But for DP it can be seen at any time and also recently (because people change their DP frequently)

Present Perfect only emphasises on the present. It doesn't change the meaning. So, both are correct but have a very minute difference.

Here's a great video to clarify this confusion.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.