3

I could not find any references to ‘naysmith’ as an actual historical term. Following is an excerpt from the book ‘Horus Rising.”

‘Then it occurs to me, Garviel, that only a weapon which questions its use could be of any value in that role. To be a member of the Mournival, you need to have concerns. You need to have wit, and most certainly you need to have doubts. Do you know what a naysmith is?’

‘No.’

‘In early Terran history, during the dominance of the Sumaturan dynasts, naysmiths were employed by the ruling classes. Their job was to disagree. To question everything. To consider any argument or policy and find fault with it, or articulate the counter position. They were highly valued.’

- Horus Rising, pg. 68

  • 7
    Nope...it sounds like a portmanteau of nay (meaning "No") and smith as in "wordsmith". ...close to Devil's Advocate, or maybe some kind of Greek chorus. Sci-fi writers often invent their own words (neologisms) to give a sense of futuristic verisimilitude. – Cascabel Jun 9 '19 at 21:33
  • 7
    It is obviously an invented word for the purposes of what sounds like a really good story. You should be aware that Nasmith (pronounced naysmith) is a family name in the UK. Not all of the members of that family would regard disagreeing with everything as a virtue. – JeremyC Jun 9 '19 at 21:45
  • 2
    Naysmith is a proper name (surname) in the English speaking world. Spelled Nasmith or Naysmith, it derives from an archaic name for the occupation of cutler. My local member of Parliament was Douglas Naysmith from 1997 to 2010. – Michael Harvey Jun 9 '19 at 21:48
  • 6
    It sounds like a naysmith is a professional naysayer. – Jason Bassford Jun 10 '19 at 3:45
  • 2
    That passage looks like a bit of classic exposition. He asks 'do you know what a naysmith is?' and explains then exactly what it means in the context of the story. The occupational-name meaning doesn't seem to be the usage here. – S Conroy Jun 10 '19 at 15:21
3

I agree with Cascabel's comment that, from the context, this sounds like a portmanteau of "nay" (meaning "no") and "smith" (possibly in allusion to blacksmith, tinsmith etc., but possibly more in it's figurative use: "A person who fashions something non-material, such as an attribute, one's destiny, etc." [OED, sense b]). In other words, someone good at saying "no" or a Devil's Advocate.

For the record, the OED does not have an entry for naysmith; the closest is their entry for "Naysmyth" which comes from John Naysmith, 1808–90, a Scottish engineer who invented both a steam hammer (or piledriver) in 1839 and a design of telescope c1942. It makes no mention of either being related to a cutler.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you. I came to the same conclusion involving it being a portmanteau. I also came across all the references every body has provided, but the story alludes to “ancient Earth” (the setting is 30k years in the future) and makes use of “evolved” language that are variations of modern day terms. I was trying to find the modern day analog for “naysmith” relative to “Sumatran Dynasts.” I also could not find much relating to Sumatran politics and the use of “professional contrarians.” It was an intriguing concept, so I was interested in the possible inspiration(s) for the term and culture. – Digcoal Aug 15 '19 at 22:06
2

From an out-of-universe perspective, the quoted passage doesn't indicate that the reader is supposed to be familiar with a word "naysmith" any more than the reader is supposed to be familiar with "Sumaturan dynasts" (which as far as I can tell are entirely fictional). The passage goes on to explain what the word means, which is exactly what would happen for an invented term.

I disagree with the suggestion that the use of the fictional term "naysmith" in this book must be related to the actually existing surname Naysmith. David Robinson's explanation seems plausible, but I think it's not completely certain: I think the only way to know for sure would be to ask Dan Abnett, the author of the book.

| improve this answer | |
1

Agree with Michael Harvey, a quick google shows that it is related to cutler. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naysmith

I also found this: https://www.surnamedb.com/Surname/Naismith

It appears the origin is from "Knifesmith".

| improve this answer | |
  • typo: cutlery, not cutler. – Lambie Jun 10 '19 at 15:21
0

It seems pretty clear here that it is a profession made up from nay "no" and smith "someone who makes something professionally" to mean "someone who makes noes professionally". It is not a portmanteau as that means "words blended together", that is, parts of words joined together, as in motel from mot(or hot)el, whereas this is two complete words joined together, just as blacksmith and goldsmith.

But it is also clear that it is not simply a neologism. The author was undoubtedly aware of the surname Naysmith (in various spellings) and was playing on the fact that the original meaning of the name is unguessable. The author's meaning looks like a plausible meaning for an existing name as it is quite logical that if a goldsmith makes gold things professionally then a naysmith makes nays professionally, just as a naysayer does as an amateur.

| improve this answer | |
0

I strongly suspect it is a reference to Bob Naismith.

He is a miniature designer who worked for Citadel Miniature in the 80's. He has notably sculpted the first Space Marine miniature.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.