0

I came across a sentence on Cambridge Dictionary. It says

If found guilty, he faces six months in jail.

They omitted "he is" right ? And can I say

If (my computer is) broken , I will fix it.

And can I also use this grammar with an active sentence

If (you) punch him, he gets hurt

Thanks in advance

2

This kind of ellipsis only works if the omission consists of the subject and a form of the verb 'to be' and the omitted subject appears in the main clause either as the subject or the object.

If (he is) found guilty, he faces six months in jail. (subject-subject)

If (my computer is) broken, I will fix it. (subject-object)

Of course, the preceding sentence is only intelligible if it is clear from the context what the it is. And some might object that the "if broken" clause is a dangling participle.

The sentence If punch him, he gets hurt does not omit the verb to be. It is both unintelligible and ungrammatical. A grammatical alternative is:

If (he is) punched, he gets angry.

  • I don't think "If (my computer is) broken, I will fix it" is correct, I would say "If broken, it will be fixed (by me)". That is, subct-subject is ok, subject-object is not. – Rusty Core Mar 25 at 15:07
  • @Rusty Core. I agree that the second sentence is somewhat problematic, particularly for those who have a strong aversion to dangling participles. There's a good article on the topic on Slate: slate.com/human-interest/2014/09/… – Shoe Mar 25 at 17:36
1

The first example only works if the context makes it clear who is being talked about.

Fred Bloggs is in court on a charge of [whatever]. If found guilty, he faces six months in jail

The 'If' phrase has to refer to the subject.

My computer is very slow. If broken, it will have to be sent away for repair is grammatical, if not very idiomatic. So, no, your third example doesn't work.

0

In the sentence from dictionary, the subject is exact in the second sentence but in your first example, it's not exact what you are talking about. "If broken, i will fix the computer" would be better, i guess

  • 1
    No, because the 'If' phrase has to refer to the subject of the sentence. Your suggestion literally means "If I am broken, I will fix the computer." – Kate Bunting Mar 25 at 8:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.