1

Consider the following sentences which utilizes the mathematical factorial operation:

The answer is 5!.

or

The equation is given by

f(x) = (x+4)!.

Typically in mathematical writing, an expression in a sentence is treated as a word and is therefore punctuated accordingly. But in this case, a period following an exclamation point looks awkward. Would a period still be used here to indicate the end of the sentence?

  • 3
    What do the other articles in the journal do? – Hot Licks Feb 6 '19 at 2:16
  • 1
    Yes. ---------- – Greg Lee Feb 6 '19 at 4:53
  • Enclose the whole item in parentheses of some sort, e.g. The answer is {5!}. or The equation is given by {f(x) = (x+4)!}. [Or if that particular kind of symbol has a special meaning, choose another - even quotation marks will do.] Note also that some style guides say not to put punctuation at the end of an indented quote, so maybe your second example doesn't need a period at all! :-) – Chappo Says SE Dudded Monica Feb 6 '19 at 6:48
  • Look up the relevant style manual and let us know. Good Luck. – Kris Feb 6 '19 at 7:25
  • I can't find any examples of this case. – GregDoesMath Feb 6 '19 at 19:14
1

The manual of style of the AMS advises:

Each mathematics equation reads as a clause or sentence and is punctuated accordingly. Authors, however, sometimes leave displayed math unpunctuated. Insert commas and periods as needed so that the equation(s), the preceding text, and the following text together read grammatically. Follow CMS, sections 12.18–12.20, for punctuating mathematical expressions and elided lists, operators, and relations.

This implies that you can choose.

I never punctuate displayed math. The capitalization, or lack of it, of the next line, the vertical spacing, and the indentation are punctuation enough. I would use a period after an inline equation, specially after a factorial, otherwise it is ambiguous if the sentence is an exclamation or an equation involving factorial.

0

The accepted answer is wrong in that "This implies that you can choose". That is only true if you have an editor that corrects your choice of not punctuating your displayed equations. This is what the AMS Style Guide means with its formulation. It states in Section 12.1 that "Many authors do not punctuate series of equations even if their text punctuation is acceptable. We edit to include this punctuation."

Mathematical expressions, including displayed equations, are treated as phrases or sentences and are punctuated accordingly. (See for example Section 12.7 of the AMS Style Guide.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.