0

I am going to examine this question in / within the context of the epistemology of memory.

I can see that both are frequently used online. Are both equally acceptable?

1

To examine something (say, a single verse in the Bible) in context is always a good idea--good hermeneutics too!

On the other hand, to stay within the confines of, say, "the epistemology of memory," is to stick to the issue at hand, which also is a good idea.

In other words, and in my opinion, the word within seems more suitable in your exemplar than the word in.

Is there a huge difference in denotation between the two words? No. On the other hand, to consider a question in context is to examine the circumstances surrounding the question, whereas to examine a question within the context is akin to bracketing the question and ignoring the surrounding circumstances, at least temporarily.

If indeed there is a difference between the two couplets, and a choice needs to be made, that difference is pretty darn subtle!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.