0

Hello beautiful people,

I am writing an exam on English grammar soon and one part is requiring you to draw a phrase diagram separating the noun phrases, verb phrases, etc..

Now I took a sentence from the first Harry Potter book (c) All rights reserved, and made it into a phrase tree.

Did I do everything correctly?

NP stands for noun phrase

VP for verb phrase

PP for prepositional phrase

Clause tree

All Feedback is appreciated!

2

I think you've diagrammed it as though Dursley is a director called Grunnings and that it's he who made drills personally. :-)

I'll let these step-by-step illustrations speak for themselves:

successive levels of diagramming for the whole sentence

Focusing on the portion of the sentence qualifying the word "director":

successive levels of diagramming for "a firm called Grunnings which made drills"

Alternatively, with the indefinite article, I think it can also be parsed this way, if we think of "Grunnings" as a unique identifier that, if applied first, would make "a" redundant, which it isn't:

Alternate treatment for the firm

I'll leave "called Grunnings" and "which made drills" as an exercise.

  • Wow, thank you very much for your awesome reply. At first I had to chuckle but now I am starting to understand. Here is also a very good graphic which helped me to understand imgur.com/a/ZVd7De6 . I will update you later on the correct graphic! :) – Hans Mo Dec 8 '18 at 13:21
0

In short, no, I don't think so. The basic structure is

NP---------------------VP

             V------------NP

Use a substitution test like He was something.

That's the top of the structure.

Then the subject complement is just

NP------------------PP

the dir.

           P------------NP

           of          
                Det-----------NP

                 a          firm

                              Reduced relative clause: [that was] called G.

                                                          Full relative clause:

                                                              NP----VP

                                                            which     V-----NP

                                                                     made  dills

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.