1

I'm posting this question to settle a debate.

Is the sentence, "If there are three of an unparalleled thing, is any of them truly unparalleled?" correct? The sentence throws me off because the first clause has a plural subject, but the second clause has a singular subject. My personal preference would be to make the subjects in both clauses plural. I.e. "If there are three of an unparalleled thing, are any of them truly unparalleled?"

On the other hand, adding "one" sounds okay too. I.e. "If there are three of an unparalleled thing, is any one of them truly unparalleled?" The addition of "one" lessens the ambiguity over whether the subject is singular or not.

closed as off-topic by Kris, Scott, jimm101, Chenmunka, curiousdannii Dec 13 '18 at 2:26

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • Okay, go ahead. – posfan12 Nov 30 '18 at 5:35
  • 1
    "Yes, one of them is." "Yes, two of them are." Now decide if there's anything still odd with the original sentence. – Kris Nov 30 '18 at 6:03
  • What? You are not making any sense. – posfan12 Nov 30 '18 at 11:01
1

There is nothing wrong with using singular and plural subjects in different clauses in the same sentence: as you yourself observe, we can say things like "If there are three of an unparalleled thing, is any one of them truly unparalleled?"

I think the reason for uncertainty about whether "any of [plural noun]" should take singular or plural verb agreement is because the noun in the prepositional phrase is plural in form, but the word any is not, and semantically it could be considered either singular or plural. For comparison, the construction "which of [plural noun]" takes singular or plural agreement depending on its meaning: we could say "Which of these squares is red" or "Which of these squares are red" depending on whether we expect a singular or plural answer.

Apparently, both usages are fairly common, but it's more common or more commonly accepted to use a singular verb with "any of [plural noun]". See CowperKettle's answer to the question "How to use “any of”" on ELL SE:

I did some googling, and it turns out any of your options is admitted: here's a link to [a grammar blog post][1]. I quote:

Any of can be followed by a verb in the singular or plural: "If any of your friends want/wants to come, they are welcome." (Plural is preferred in everyday language, singular is more formal)

Or, as the same issue it treated in [a grammar rule sheet][2] at a New Zealand university site,

When any of is followed by a countable plural noun, the verb can be in either singular or plural form, but a singular verb is more common in a formal style: "If any of your friends is/are interested, let me know."

Unfortunately, both of the links seem to be broken, so I haven't reproduced them.

I found a post with a relevant quotation from the archive of the Pearson Longman Grammar Exchange Questions and Answers Newsgroup. Rachel posted a message with the following quotation (I have not checked the quoted source directly):

"When none, neither, either and any are followed by "of + plural noun/pronoun," they are normally used with singular verbs in a formal style in British English. Plural verbs are common in informal British usage and generally in American English.

None of the cures really works. (formal British)

None of the cures really work. (informal British; American)

Neither of my brothers has/ have been outside England.

Has/Have either of them been seen recently?

If any of the children gets/ get hungry, they can have an orange."

(Michael Swan, Practical English Usage, Second Edition (Oxford University Press, 1995. Page 534)

  • Could be simpler than that. – Kris Nov 30 '18 at 6:01
  • @Kris: I don't understand what you mean! – sumelic Nov 30 '18 at 6:02
  • Please see my comment at OP. This is an English Language Learners question. – Kris Nov 30 '18 at 6:03
  • I don't understand, either. – posfan12 Nov 30 '18 at 10:47

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.