0

The example that I have is from South Africa. Chartered accountants here abbreviate their titles in emails to:

CA(SA)

This is meant to abbreviate "Chartered Accountant (South Africa)". I feel, however, that this may be a mistake that is propagated by a precedent set by other accountants.

Is it not more correct to use a space?

CA (SA)

Orthographically, this seems more consistent to me.

EDIT:

There is no question about spaces in the original phrase: "Chartered Accountant (South Africa)". Instead, the question is about whether parentheses need spaces when the whole phrase is abbreviated.

EDIT 2:

The general question is: How does a bracket, preceded by a space, compile to an abbreviation? When the phrase in question refers to a named entity it seems like common courtesy is to use whichever style the entity itself prefers.

  • Does it really matter? And if so, why? – BillJ Oct 19 '18 at 16:21
  • I am not sure what constitutes whether something matters, but I prefer there to be a correct way, even if multiple options are correct. – mikorym Oct 20 '18 at 17:09
  • But from functional point of view, all South African accountants sign their emails with "CA(SA)" so it is a abbreviation in common circulation. Commonly used language usually appears in style guides with recommendations; however, in this case I have not seen any linguistic recommendations. Specifically, I am curious about how a phrase containing parentheses compiles to an abbreviation. – mikorym Oct 20 '18 at 17:16
  • Possible duplicate of Do parentheses need spaces either side? – Jason Bassford Oct 20 '18 at 17:26
  • The difference here is that the whole of "CA(SA)" / "CA (SA)" is an abbreviation. However, your link does explain why I prefer there to always be spaces before an opening parenthesis. – mikorym Oct 20 '18 at 17:30
0

The first thing to consider is that we all have a right to our name, and second we need to understand the original concept and needs of the users.

While I was at university, a student living next door had his name changed by deed poll to 'Dill the dog'. This was his right, and if I had told he was wrong then I would have been in the wrong.

Chartered accountants deal with a lot of data, which often ends up being squeezed into innumerable tables, so they have a tendency to choose concise acronyms and titling.

I cannot access the SAICA page at the moment, but I can see that the Wikipedia page uses CA(SA) and the plural CAs(SA), and that it is used to express their qualification of chartered accountant. Wikipedia

  • Thanks for your input. I understand that when referring to a name, correctness is more subtle. But in general, are there style guidelines for a phrase that contains parentheses? – mikorym Oct 20 '18 at 17:17
  • @mikorym There are so many different style guidelines for different publications that that is an impossible Q. to answer. As regards comments about a space before the brackets, if you followed that to its logical conclusion, you would have to write "C A (S A)" because there are spaces between all the words in the original. Why put spaces before the brackets, but not before the individual word contractions? – TrevorD Apr 21 at 13:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.