0

Recently a student of mine made the following mistake : "I want my family don't need anything". I corrected it to "I want my family not to need anything". But when asked why I used "not to" instead of "don't", I couldn't explain why.

Can anybody help me with this?

Thank you very much.

  • Does it help simplify things if you take out the negation and compare “I want my family to need” vs. “I want my family need”/“I want my family do need”? – Ry- Oct 15 '18 at 15:59
  • I would have corrected it to "I want my family to not need anything" in this case the split infinitive makes the sentence meaning clearer. – JeffUK Oct 15 '18 at 16:44
  • Hm... would "I want that my family don't need anything" be considered correct? – Mr Lister Oct 15 '18 at 18:30
  • Hello, thank you all for your help! It was explained to be by a colleague: – Dayle Oct 16 '18 at 19:28
  • With the verbs want and expect you have to put an infinitive not an auxiliary. – Dayle Oct 16 '18 at 19:31
3

The verb want takes an infinitive after it, not an auxiliary verb.

For example, you can't say

*I want can fly.

You have to say

I want to be able to fly.

-1

To want takes an object, when that object is a thing.

I want a pony.

I want more money.

I want world peace.

To want takes to + infinitive, when an action is wanted, for the subject to do.

I want to sleep.

I don’t want to work.

I want to go to the beach.

I want to be able to fly.

To want takes an object + to + infinitive, when an action is wanted, for another person to do.

I want the baby to sleep.

I want him to work.

I want you to go to the beach with me.

I want my brother to be able to swim.

I don’t want them to need me.

I want my family not to need anything.

To want can also take a noun clause describing an action, starting with that. But these formulations are not preferred. The ones above sound better.

I want that the baby sleeps.

I want that I can fly.

I want that my brother can swim.

I don’t want that they need me.

I want that my family doesn’t need anything.

You can add stress by changing the order of the sentence, starting with the noun clause, and referring to it with a second that.

That my family doesn’t need anything, that’s what I want!

That works with regular objects as well.

A pony, that’s what I want!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.