2

An example:

Coffee? Why are you asking if I want coffee?

Here the speaker, depending on context, means to say that they either want coffee or don't want it and that, in either case, this should be obvious. The general pattern is essentially: "X? [rhetorical question involving X]" This instance appears to be a form of hypophora but I was wondering if there is any more specific term.

  • 1
    If there is a relevant literary term I'd expect it to also apply to, for example, Stars. He saw stars, and not just the ones lighting the sky above him - the distinguishing feature being "restatement", regardless of whether the element being repeated / clarified is a question or a statement. – FumbleFingers Sep 18 '18 at 11:59
  • 2
    Things don't have to fall into a single category. It is definitely a rhetorical question. But the repetition of X, there a number of named rhetorical tropes that might fit; symploce seems closest. – Mitch Sep 18 '18 at 12:23
3

Hypophora is also known as anthypophora and Sylva Rhetoricæ explains that it is

A figure of reasoning in which one asks and then immediately answers one's own questions (or raises and then settles imaginary objections). Reasoning aloud.

Anthypophora sometimes takes the form of asking the audience or one's adversary what can be said on a matter, and thus can involve both anacoenosis and apostrophe.

That site gives this example of its usage:

"But there are only three hundred of us," you object. Three hundred, yes, but men, but armed, but Spartans, but at Thermoplyae: I have never seen three hundred so numerous. — Seneca

Although hypophora and anthypophora once meant the same thing, they have drifted apart in recent times. Wikipedia notes that

A division has arisen between the definitions of hypophora and anthypophora. The Century Dictionary identifies hypophora as the dissenting statement or question and anthypophora as the reply to the question.[5] Thus the two terms have come to embrace both elements of hypophora, as well as dealing with the whole concept.

Your question appears to be about the hypophora portion alone, and I can tell you that there appears to be no more specific term for that concept. You can get by simply by calling it a "rhetorical question," and though that is much more general a statement that is the one that will be more familiar to your audience. Unless that audience is well-versed in rhetoric, the more precise terms are likely to produce only blank stares.

  • I don't have an audience though. Somebody posed the question to me and I went hunting for an answer, eventually leading me here. – readyready15728 Sep 18 '18 at 13:42
  • @Sadiq: An audience can be anyone, even a single person, such as the person who posed the question to you (or whomever that person wished to address). – Robusto Sep 18 '18 at 14:28
  • Yes but I don't expect any blank stares. – readyready15728 Sep 19 '18 at 15:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.