0

Consider the following sentence:

"Is there anything you could say which would still be extant in 24 hours time?"

Does it make sense to use the word 'extant' to mean that some proposition would still be true at some time rather than that some object is still in existence?

Cheers folks.

-1

Extant is quite different from existent.

It is derived from the Latin exstat, meaning literally it stands out. It is a term of scholarly. It related to documents and. writings that are no longer available even though they are known to have existed. So many of the volumes of the History of the Roman historian Livy are no longer extant (except in fragments quoted by others or in Reader’s Digest style ‘epitomes’.). The writings of the Greek Atomist, Democritus and other pre-socratic cosmologists are lost (apart from isolated citations) because they clashed with early Christian dogma. These are known works, such as a great work by The Alexandrian Theophrastus on the early Greek philosophers, which are no longer extant. But archaeologists keep discovering papyrus fragments, such as a complete comedy by Menander, found in an ancient landfill site outside ancient Oxyrrinchus in the desert towards the Nile delta. Others may be found. So they may be among the known works of literature, history, religion or whatever, so it is not quite right to say they do not exist. So we say they are no longer extant.

  • 1
    Macmillan has a nice straightforward definition: "still existing, usually despite being very old." You're right that it's usually applied to books and documents but it's also used with buildings or works of art, for instance, and other suitably old things that have managed to persist. – tmgr Sep 18 '18 at 10:54
  • @tmgr Yes, although I think it would be odd to say of (say) the former Royal Palace of Westminster that it is ‘no longer extant.’. From the examples in the online Oxford dictionary, it appears that the core idea is ‘continued availability for study’. At the edges it can find itself used just to mean ‘no longer existing’ – Tuffy Sep 18 '18 at 17:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.