2

I'm not sure whether the following sentences are grammatically correct:

A figure appeared at the window, waving happily.

and,

"Sure," he answered, pulling out a chair at the nearby table.

Both sentences sound fine when I read them aloud, but they switch tenses after the comma that leads me to the confusion. Is this correct or incorrect? And if it is correct, what grammar rules would allow verb tense to be changed in such a way?

0

There isn't anything necessarily wrong with switching verb tenses in a sentence. It may often lead to awkwardness but it doesn't always.

In this case, there is no problem. In fact, there isn't really a switch in verb tenses at all.

The reason there isn't a problem in either of these sentences is because the second verbs used are both present participles. They end in -ing and take the same form regardless of any other verb tense:

A figure appeared at the door, waving happily.
A figure appears at the door, waving happily.
A figure will appear at the door, waving happily.

No matter what verb tense is used elsewhere, it will always be waving that is used.

The present participle is described as present, but it's actually present relative to whatever other verb is being used. For example, if a past tense verb is used, then the present participle is relative to it—and it takes place in the past.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.