2

I am currently running for the Board of Education in my little town and am working on my candidate statement for the election handbook that the Department of Elections produces. I sent what I had to a friend who is a great editor and she questioned the following bit of text:

For some, sports are a motivation to do well in school; we need to ensure that the artistically- and scientifically-minded students have as much encouragement and support as the athletically-gifted students.

Specifically, she asked about the "adverbs artistically and scientifically versus adjectives artistic and scientific modifying minded". She noted that she thought the adverbs were correct, but wasn't sure why. (I'm not sure why either, but that applies to almost everything anyway.)

So I went and looked up both the adjective and adverb forms in the Oxford Dictionaries to see what I could find out. Here are those definitions:

artistic

ADJECTIVE

  1. Having or revealing natural creative skill.

    ‘my lack of artistic ability’

artistically

ADVERB

  1. As regards art or artists; from an artistic point of view.

    ‘the Soviet film industry was artistically limited by outside pressures’
    ‘her home was cosy and so artistically decorated for Christmas’

scientific

ADJECTIVE

  1. Based on or characterized by the methods and principles of science.

    ‘the scientific study of earthquakes’

scientifically

ADVERB

  1. By means of scientific methods and principles.

    ‘scientifically proven treatments’
    ‘both theories can be explained scientifically’

    1.1 In a way that relates to or is used in science.

    ‘scientifically minded people’
    ‘a scientifically important site’

The sample sentences for scientifically actually include the exact phrase I'm using -- scientifically minded -- so I'm pretty sure I'm correct in using the adverb forms. When I looked up minded, it too had the same adverbial example:

minded

ADJECTIVE

  1. [in combination or with submodifier] Inclined to think in a particular way.

    ‘liberal-minded scholars’
    ‘I'm not scientifically minded’

    1.1 [in combination] Interested in or enthusiastic about a particular thing.

    ‘conservation-minded citizens’

However, I note that the other examples here use adjectives: liberal-minded instead of liberally-minded and conservation-minded instead of conservationally-minded. I also note that the examples that use an adjective are hyphenated while the one with an adverb is not.

So my question is, why do some -minded phrases take adjectives while others take adverbs? Also, is the correlation between type of modifier and the presence of a hyphen significant or coincidental?

1

According to the Collins English Dictionary,"-minded" combines with 3 parts of speech: adjectives, adverbs and nouns.

  1. "-minded" combines with adjectives to form words that describe someone's character, attitude, opinions, or intelligence: These are evil-minded people.
  2. "-minded" combines with adverbs to form adjectives that indicate that someone is interested in a particular subject or is able to think in a particular way: I am not an academically-minded person.
  3. "-minded" combines with nouns to form adjectives that indicate that someone thinks a particular thing is important or cares a lot about it: He is seen as more business-minded than his predecessor.

As for the hyphen, it should be used with the combining form "-minded".

  • @JasonBassford Right. But I mean if we use "minded", we should put a hyphen before this combining form. I am not talking about any other compound adjectives - only those using "-minded". – Enguroo Aug 8 '18 at 0:01
  • @JasonBassford However, I see that in British English "minded" is an adjective meaning "having a mind, inclination, intention, etc, as specified": politically minded. But then again they give the example "money-minded", which uses a hyphen. Please check it out collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/minded_1. – Enguroo Aug 8 '18 at 0:06
  • @JasonBassford They appear to be differentiating between "minded" as a combing form and "minded" as an adjective. As far as I understand, whether to use a hyphen or not depends on your perception. – Enguroo Aug 8 '18 at 0:16
0

I started to address your question, but then realized it's actually more complicated than I had thought.

First, look at Oxford's definition of the adjective liberal-minded:

In early use: having a generous character or disposition. Later: holding liberal opinions; tolerant, broad-minded.

Now, look at its definition of the adverb liberally:

  1. In large or generous amounts.
    ‘she quotes liberally from the Bible’
    ‘steaks liberally sprinkled with salt and pepper’
    ‘large firms contributed liberally to the relief fund’

  2. In a way that is not precise or strictly literal; loosely.
    ‘the law is interpreted liberally’
    ‘the obligations of treaties should be liberally construed’

  3. In a way that involves broadening a person's general knowledge and experience.
    ‘liberally educated students’

  4. In a way that favours individual liberty and moderate political and social reform.
    ‘I used to think more liberally’

A liberal-minded student student makes sense. But a liberally minded student seems a little odd. Depending on the sense of liberally, it may not mean exactly the same thing—or it may mean something strange.

I would say that, idiomatically, liberal-minded is what would normally be used.


As for artistic-minded student and artistically minded student, I would say that the reverse is true; that the use of the adverb is simply more common and, therefore, more natural.

There is no dictionary definition of the compound adjective artistic-minded that I can find. Without a dictionary definition, it becomes a constructed compound adjective.

I'd like to say that it sounds awkward and, therefore, nobody uses it—but that's not true.

A Google search turns up several uses of artistic-minded.

It's used in "A Visit to Ceylon" by George J. Romanes (emphasis mine):

We had, of course, read a good deal about Ceylon before, and thus knew that it was a part of the world which in point alike of natural scenery and natural history was well calculated to arouse the enthusiasm of such an artistic-minded naturalist as Prof. Haeckel; and knowing that his pen can paint almost as vividly as his brush, we were prepared for something of unusual interest in the story of his “Visit to Ceylon.”

It's used on the Centre Clark website (emphasis mine):

Following its initial mandate, CLARK has put forth numerous projects. Not only artistic-minded, but also community and educational as well. In parallel to its’ programming, it has completed several projects – both here and abroad.

So, I can't give a good answer as to why (besides rules of grammar that would indicate one or the other) sometimes the adjective is used and sometimes the adverb is used.

Although one form is likely more common, and that's the one that sounds more natural, it seems that it's just a matter of preference.


I can speak to the use of hyphens.

When forming a compound adjective, one where multiple adjectives are used in front of a noun, there is a series of guidelines that takes place.

Some compound adjectives are joined with a hyphen and others are not:

Here are some examples:

a five-year-old child
eighteen years of age
a second-best decision
he arrived fourth to last

The Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed.) has a hyphenation guide that is twelve-pages of nothing but specific examples and guidelines; and that's in addition to several other pages of general guidelines.

However, in general, that's why you see liberal-minded student but liberally minded student.

One specific rule from Chicago (7.86) talks about adverbs that end in ly:

Compounds formed by an adverb ending in ly plus an adjective or participle (such as largely irrelevant or smartly dressed) are not hyphenated either before or after a noun, since ambiguity is virtually impossible. (The ly ending with adverbs signals to the reader that the next word will be another modifier, not a noun.)

As I understand it, the majority of style guides and grammarians follow this guideline. That's why most recipes call for finely chopped onions and not finely-chopped onions.

Knowing this, I am at a loss to understand why Collins uses a hyphen in two example sentences formed by an ly adverb in its definition of -minded:

I am not an academically-minded person.
He was not mechanically-minded.

This goes against common stylistic rules, and doesn't match other dictionaries:

[Oxford's definition of scientifically]

‘scientifically minded people’
‘a scientifically important site’

[Your Dictionary's definition of scientifically]

In support of this belief there is more or less scientifically ascertained evidence

However, I can say with a fair degree of confidence that it's much more common to not use a hyphen in the constructions artistically minded students, scientifically minded students, and athletically gifted student.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.