3

Today I heard someone on television say this:

In the battle between x versus y, x won.

Is this correct? In my opinion, this would sound better/be more correct:

In the battle between x and y, x won.

What should have been said?

9

Technically speaking, the phrase should have been either

The battle of X versus Y

or

The battle between X and Y

I think it's more common to say "The battle of (placename)" or "the battle between x and y" instead of "the battle of x versus y", but I'll have to let someone else try to NGram that up.

However, I'm guessing that you were watching a show called "Man versus Food", and the host of the show isn't about to miss a chance to slip the name of the show in even if it makes the sentence sound a little funny.

  • That was the show. I suppose you're right. – user11550 Oct 19 '11 at 12:23
1

Here's some Ngrams that show "battle between X and Y" is much more common than both "battle of X versus Y" and "battle between X versus Y", which you can't even see above the zero baseline:

England France Athens Alexander

  • There's some awfully strange clustering in those graphs... – Karl Knechtel Oct 19 '11 at 12:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy