2

Lets say I'm describing a musical genre, like post-punk. I want to create a song that's so advanced past post-punk, that I want to call it post-post-punk. However, the double-post looks abhorrent and silly.

Is there anything that can represent this idea of having a double "post" prefix, or even double any prefix?

  • 1
    After 'post modernism' came post-postmodernism. – Nigel J May 21 '18 at 12:32
  • @NigelJ That sounds about right, and may be the only option here. However, the whole idea of looking for an alternate prefix is to avoid having "post-post" as the prefix. – dynastic May 21 '18 at 12:33
  • It seems to me that "post-post-punk" should look abhorrent. – Hot Licks May 21 '18 at 12:46
  • (The problem you run into is that any term you try will basically be a synonym for "post", making it unclear what the sequence is.) – Hot Licks May 21 '18 at 12:47
  • 1
    I've always thought the whole point of punk music was that it represented a rejection of earlier musical conventions. So it's a bit ironic that in addition to the well-established usage post-punk, we now have OP seeking to define "musical form based on rejection of an earlier musical form which was itself based on rejection of an even earlier form*. You'd think after a couple of "generations", the newest form might more sensibly be named according to what it is, not (recursively) what it's not. – FumbleFingers May 21 '18 at 14:43
2

A movement, genre, or school of thought termed post-x means that its continuation of and reaction to x are in significant ways defining. The same would go for post-post-x; otherwise, a new term would be chosen. For instance, I don’t believe anyone refers to the Vietnam era as post-post-war, although it can be principally defined as a wholesale rejection of Eisenhower’s America, particularly among the young. Besides, a post-post-war war in southeast Asia would be too much of a reduplicated stew to digest.

“Post-post-x” can also be meant ironically or as a question, “So what comes after post-x?” In this sense, the coinage is often a nonce word created primarily to carry the ironic or interrogative meaning rather than designate a cultural phenomenon.

Post-post-race is the title of a hiphop album by Katrah-Quey and vocalist Guante whose lyrics deal with racism after the prematurely declared post-racial era.

enter image description here

A writer in Austria asks:

What is “Post-Post”? Post-media, post-web and post-digital are the new buzzwords of our times. Media are now available everywhere and anytime; in fact, it is becoming difficult to switch them off and remain “off-grid.” Smart devices, geo media and surveillance systems are spinning a dense panoptic web all around us. The physical world is becoming increasingly infiltrated by digital technologies, while social networks have turned us into “smart mobs” whose behavior can be foreseen and pre-calculated.

An investment firm uses the double prefix without a hint of irony:

Mike Gitlin, head of fixed income for Capital Group, explains why we’re in a “post-post-crisis era,” the term he uses to characterize today’s global economy.

Whether Mr. Gatlin is correct in proclaiming a new era in an economy now fully recovered from the financial crisis, he suggests that conditions for investment have changed, requiring new strategies which his firm would be happy to provide.

Further used in an essentially interrogative sense: university mission and identity for a post post‐public era, post-post-structuralism, and post-post-truth.

With far fewer question marks in post-post-feminism, post-post-postcolonial South Africa, and post-post-9/11.

And, of course, the well established post-postmodern:

enter image description here

If you wish to portray the music for which you’re seeking a genre designation as both continuation and reaction to post-punk, you’re basically stuck with the double prefix unless you, say, make an argument for “late post-punk” or dodge the bullet entirely by labelling it by the decade in which it appeared.

-2

What I decided to go with is ceno-

From Dictionary.com:

a combining form meaning “new,” “recent,” used in the formation of compound words

This is slightly different than the meaning of post-post-, but conveys the idea that I was originally looking for: the most recent iteration of the subject matter.

So, post-punk is a genre with roots in punk rock, but takes on different ideas. Ceno-punk would be the next iteration of that.

  • 2
    Sorry, dynastic. ELU is about the discovery and analysis of accepted English usage, not DIY inventions. The explanation of what meaning the prefix ceno has in words in the lexicon does not mean that 'ceno-punk', 'ceno-Baroque', 'ceno-ska', 'ceno-R&B' etc are acceptable. This doesn't mean you can't use them, but it does mean they're off-topic on ELU. – Edwin Ashworth May 21 '18 at 12:55
  • 1
    @EdwinAshworth I wasn't exactly looking to invent something, I was just using musical genre as an example. Thanks for the heads up though, I'll be more careful in the future. – dynastic May 21 '18 at 12:57
  • Ceno- is only used in a few specialized scientific coinages with root words of Greek origin: it only means 'new' in Cenozoic. In cenobite and cenospecies it means 'common', as in Koiné Greek. In cenotaph 'empty tomb', it's a different word entirely. This isn't what you're looking for, unless your readers include significant numbers of people interested in biology, anthropology, religious history, or dead languages. – KarlG May 21 '18 at 16:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.