1

Is it correct to say you will "break in a pair of shoes" or you will "break a pair of shoes in". I'm not sure if it's regional, or just altogether unimportant, but I've certainly heard both and I was wondering if there is a more technically correct way to phrase it.

Another example would be "To break in a glove" or "To break a glove in".

1

The Oxford Dictionary of Phrasal Verbs marks this sense of break in as being optionally separable. That is, 'break in [something]' and 'break [something] in' are both acceptable (this is not the case with all multi-word verbs).

There are two provisos:

(1) the MWV is obligatorily separable with pronoun 'prepositional objects' ('break them in', not 'break in them')

(2) the MWV is obligatorily inseparable for weightier 'prepositional objects' ( Over the next few weeks, the wranglers broke in the dozen or so wild mustangs that the cowboys had managed to corral in the box canyon).

...............

There is a requirement with this MWV that the referent of the 'prepositional object' be of a rather more exacting nature than say a feather duster. Gloves are probably borderline. You'd only use 'I broke in a new feather duster' whimsically. // I'd prefer object of the transitive MWV to 'prepositional object' here.

  • 1
    I cancelled the down-vote as I appreciate that you cannot link to the OED of Phrasal Verbs as it is not online. – Nigel J May 11 '18 at 12:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.