1

Rodney Huddleston argued that grammars should only allow for “inflectional distinction” between two forms of a verb when “there is at least one lexeme with a stable contrast in realisation between those two forms” (76). However, in the verb paradigm “with six forms” that he lays out, what he calls the primary plain form and the secondary plain form are syncretic in take, hit, and want, the examples he gives (74).

If “form” means the same thing on page 74 and 76, it seems like there must be a verb whose primary and secondary plain form varies, or else Huddleston wouldn’t have made them separate forms, by his own criterion.

Is there such a verb? (Or am I confused? (Or is Huddleston confused?))

Cited: Rodney Huddleston, “The verb” in The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language (2002, Cambridge UP).

Huddleston's verb paradigm.

  • You should edit your question so that it can be understood by people who don't have the book. – Laurel Mar 25 '18 at 4:25
  • They are separate forms because although they share the same shape, they belong in distinct subclasses within the paradigm. Importantly, a distinction is necessary since the present tense plain heads finite VPs, while the plain form heads non-finite ones; hence the contrast between primary and secondary forms. Note that the verb "be" has distinct shapes for the two forms. – BillJ Mar 25 '18 at 7:22
  • @BillJ Hey, that's an answer! Let me give you answer points. – nebuch Mar 25 '18 at 15:15
2

They are separate forms because although they share the same shape, they belong in distinct subclasses within the paradigm. Importantly, a distinction is necessary since the present tense plain heads finite VPs, while the plain form heads non-finite ones; hence the contrast between primary and secondary forms.

Note that the verb "be" has distinct shapes for the two forms.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.