Recently I have watched the film "The Shack". The events of the film is narrated by a person who is also a character in the film (Willie). At the beginning he gives some information about Mackenzie's(main character) father. Here it is:

His father was an elder in the church. A closet drinker.

Especially when the rain didn't come, or came too early...

Most times in between.

The first line is clear: The man is a worker in the church and he is not supposed to drink but he brakes this rule.

I didn't understand the second line. Why the narrator is mentioning rain? How can it be related to the closet drinker?

The third line will get cleared, I think, if the second line gets cleared first. Can anybody explain what the narrator means in the second line?


The second line would make sense were Mackenzie's father a farmer who depended upon the right amount of rain at the right time for a successful harvest. There is something of a joke regarding his drinking in the last line. It implies that while he may consider a drought or a too-early rain as a disaster justifying his taking a drink, the fact is that he drinks regardless.

Hope this helps!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.