1

In a TV documentary we heard the sentence "X announced that, whenever Y happens, they will react by doing Z, as in the following scene". After that we saw X doing Z. What is the implication of the word scene?

  1. We saw a recording of X actually doing Z
  2. We saw a scripted event of X doing Z for the camera
  3. We saw some actors disguised as X doing Z
  4. No implication at all, "scene" can be used for all of the above

Please note X was a group of anonymous members, so although I skipped the context here, it doesn't give away much.

3

Scene does carry an implication of something enscenated, so I would not expect to see the real X actually doing something, but rather actors portraying what has been described.

That is not to say that there are no documentaries where X could cooperate and actualy do the acting themselves, so 2 could be possible (I recently saw a documentary where a situation was played out by actors, based on teh description of an actual "x", where the actual "X" played a part as well, albeit not themselves...)

When making a documentary, I guess for situation 1 I would not use scene but something along the lines of as can be seen in the following footage.

  • I'd replace it with "section", I think, for a documentary. – Max Williams Nov 28 '17 at 12:16
  • @MaxWilliams it depends on whether ther eis a whole section of the documentary set aside for documenting X doing Z or whether it is indeed just some seconds of footage showing X doing Z. There are plenty of options, but if I have actual footage of X doing Z, the point is that I wouldn't describe it as a scene. – oerkelens Nov 28 '17 at 12:19
  • Yes, "section" is quite vague I suppose. I agree with the main point, that "scene" isn't suitable for things which aren't staged, such as real footage. Some sections of a documentary might be staged though, so could be called scenes perhaps. – Max Williams Nov 28 '17 at 12:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.