6

Rather than defend myself, I took a deep breath and tried to see his point of view.

In the above sentence, than is a preposition. So I thought the verb defend should have a form of -ing like than defending myself.

Why is the verb defend in the plain form?

3

I think "than" is being used as a subordinating conjunction - introducing an exception or contrast. So I am not sure your concern applies.

-1

What you're seeing here is a contrast between spoken English and written English. In the written form, the writer can typically consider the thought in its entirety, and apply a grammatical rule to the entire construction. Doubly so if the work is proofread and corrected.

In spoken English, the thoughts are assembled as they take shape in the speaker's mind. Rather than defend myself is an exceptionally strong statement related to self-preservation (even an argument can count here), so as an idiom it takes a simple form that emphasizes the verb.

Also, in spoken English the speaker may not be conscious of what they will say next, so after a strong introductory phrase, it's possible to hear a wide variety of constructions, e.g.

  • Rather than fight, they chose to surrender.

  • Rather than surrender, they died to the last man.

  • Anyway, rather than die in silence, the sergeant called them to attention and began the first words of God Save the Queen. Didn't make any sense, really. Whole damn war was like that. But they sang it all the same.

Edited to add:

One could imagine a difference between the simple verb and the gerund as follows:

  • Rather than surrender, they fell upon their swords and died. Decision.

  • Rather than surrendering, they fell back gradually into the marshland, scattering onto paths where the mounted knights could not pursue them. Continuing action.

After writing these examples, it seems to me that the simple verb is used to express will of some kind. It carries more emotional weight, and seems more natural in spoken English.

  • Sorry, Global. No such Question depends on any difference between spoken and written language, unless you provide some examples… – Robbie Goodwin Oct 4 '17 at 23:08
  • Rather than argue, I'll let the community respond as it will. – Global Charm Oct 5 '17 at 17:33
  • Thanks, Global and I thought the Question spoke for itself and you side-stepped the important bits to post about something quite different… Spoken, written or transmitted telepathically there are four possibilities here and I thought your post ignored all of them. Is it true that defend and defending are both correct? Is it true that defend is correct and defending is wrong? Is it true that defend is wrong and defending is correct? Is it true that defend and defending are both wrong? What other possibility do you see? – Robbie Goodwin Oct 5 '17 at 20:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.