1

I recently found a lot of my friends were using "over" with an adjective describing their well-being/how they felt, e.g. "I'm sad over something/somebody" which in my opinion sounds somewhat off(?). As far as I'm concerned "about" would sound a lot more accurate.

I tried to find some difference between them and the only one I could find till now was that over appears to be used more often when the state of being relates to a person ("sad over someone"). However, I also found that "sad over a breakup" is used quite often as well (which isn't a person since it's "something"). Accordingly, I'm not entirely sure which one is right or rather sounds better.

Moreover, I'm wondering if this construction works with other adjectives like "sad", too, as in "I'm happy/relieved/etc. over something/someone".

|improve this question
  • 1
    This article from lingohelp.me gives a crude overview. But I'm sure you're right that the prepositional object influences the choice of the preposition. / In the first example b you give (sad P John), I think 'sad for John' sounds best and is the most idiomatic. You can investigate Google Ngrams for 'sad for/over/about/... John/him' yourself. But I'd use 'I'm sad about John losing his dad' (your first example a). 'I'm sad over the breakup' also works, but I don't think I'd use 'I'm sad over John'. – Edwin Ashworth Aug 7 '17 at 9:28
  • Choice of preposition is idiosyncratic. 'Happy P ...', ''Relieved P ...' etc are all individual cases; expecting an easy general rule is wildly optimistic. But if you post any individual questions, you should (1) make sure they haven't been asked here before, and (2) add basic research (found perhaps by googling "preposition with sad" etc. – Edwin Ashworth Aug 7 '17 at 9:33
2

This is likely related to the much more common phrase crying over a person or thing. Different emotional gerunds seem to take different prepositions in common parlance, e.g.

  • crying over you
  • laughing at him
  • cheering for them

These are all actions you take when feeling some emotion at another person or thing, though despite their seeming transitive nature they are usually intransitive. Note that even when "at" is used, it does not mean you are literally doing this in front of them (contrast with "snarling at you", which requires one to be present and snarling in person).

It seems quite likely that "crying over" a thing led to being "sad over" it. This is probably why other adjectives don't seem to fit: you don't "laugh over" someone, so being happy over them doesn't seem to fit either.

Now, as to why we have different prepositions for different actions, I wouldn't dare to even venture a guess.

|improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.